up vote 1 down vote favorite
share [g+] share [fb]

After using 'top' for long time, albeit basically, I have grown to distrust it's '% CPU' column reports. I have a 8-core (quad core Intel i7 920 with hyperthreading) hardware, and see some wild numbers when running a process that should not use more than 5% overall. top happily reports 50%, and I suspect it is not so.

My question is, is it a known fact that it's inaccurate when several CPUs/cores are present?

I used 'mpstat' from the 'sysstat' package, and it's showings are much more conservative, certainly within my expectations. I did press '1' for 'top' to switch it to show all the core and us/sy/io stats, but the numbers are substantially higher than with 'mpstat'...

I know that my expectations can be unfound as well, but my gut feeling tells me 'top' is wrong! :-)

The reason I need to know is because the process I am monitoring only guarantees quality of service with CPU usage "less than 80%" (however vague that sounds), and I need to know how much headroom I have left. It's a streaming server.

link|improve this question
What CPU usage number in top do you talk about? Single or SMP mode? – honk May 1 '10 at 21:58
Both single and SMP report a total that is about twice as high as numbers reported by mpstat. – amn May 2 '10 at 23:14
Try to install htop. That is is a better version (in my opinion) of top. See what results you get there first. – Waxhead Dec 11 '11 at 22:53
feedback

1 Answer

up vote 1 down vote

My guess is that a full load on your system would be 800% (100% for each core)

link|improve this answer
Well, isn't 800% a mathematical impossibility or something :-) That's sort of what it boils down to - wouldn't it be better for 'top' to adjust its reports so that 100% is 100% of the entire CPU array usage space? So, currently, my 50% reported have to be divided by 8 to get a more meaningful number, right? – amn May 2 '10 at 11:23
Although 800% seems silly, it makes it obvious that multiple cores are being used. I think it's a reasonable kludge when you don't have a distinct list of CPU utilization per core. Scaling the measurement to be within 100% wouldn't tell the user if a process was multi-core or not. – Neil May 12 '11 at 16:30
feedback

Your Answer

 
or
required, but never shown
discard

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.