My single core PIV died recently. It ran at 1.7 Ghz on 1GB RAM with integrated video. I had added a 128MB PCI nVidia FX5200 for a time I had played "2.5D" and a few 3D games, and 9 months ago replaced it with a cheap $80 nVidia GS 8400 on twice as much video RAM. That was lacking, yet better than a dual-core laptop running the same game at the same 1.7Ghz without dedicated video.

My new PC has 6GB RAM and only PCI-express ports, making my GS 8400 non-transferable to the new PC. Its quad core AMD II X4 640 at 3Ghz seems better, running around 25% load at every core in windowed mode with the little demand levels of Runes of Magic. I'd like to eventually test City of Heroes for a month or two after an absense of 3 years. Nothing more, no Crysis, StarCraft, or games that need DirectX 11 plus next years' hardware today.

I'm a very casual gamer and just kinda check fluidity of framerates and so on, and then stop playing in a week or three. City of Heroes was very demanding back on the FX5200 I had for the old PC and perhaps must have evolved to even more demands than my integrated ATI Radeon HD 4200 (1GB shared) can satisfy.

Should I pay another $80 on a current bargain card compatible with my new PC or just believe in power of the cores?

If suggesting a card, keep in mind my frequent tests with Ubuntu linux: should the purchase be nVidia, or a new ATI?

link|improve this question

2  
Just a general comment - more complex games make use of hardware features (fogging, shading, hidden line removal etc.) algorithms that are built into the graphics card and so pure CPU core power is not going to compensate for the lack of those features – Linker3000 May 17 '11 at 21:51
1  
Just to backup what Linker3000 said, I fried my two SLI'd video cards and was forced to replace them temporarily with a single bargain rack gpu. Despite using the same core 2 quad there was an ENORMOUS drop in performance for high end games. – Blomkvist May 17 '11 at 23:18
Thanks. I know about Intel being a huge drag AND having bugs that sometimes allowed me to see through walls in competitive games :). . All the nice shader / bloom effects tend to get implemented on cards you buy rather than what you're forced to get. I thought maybe I'd slow down buying a card for what little use I give them. I will probably hold everything till AFTER I get new games – Vlueboy May 17 '11 at 23:52
feedback

closed as off topic by studiohack May 17 '11 at 21:48

Questions on Super User are expected to generally relate to computer software or computer hardware, within the scope defined in the faq.

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.