up vote 1 down vote favorite
share [g+] share [fb]

I have an eVGA 680i SLI motherboard, it has sat around for a while after I stopped using it because it seemed to be "killing" hard drives left and right.

Is there anyway I can test the SATA controller to see if it functions correctly?

What the heck would cause the SATA controller to kill disks?

As far as the drives, they were mixed. The first one I think lasted 2 years it was a Seagate 7200.11.

I tested that drive on another machine and was truly dead (bad pick?). The next one was drive of the same model purchased around the same time, it just sat in the box though. Dead with in 6 months. Then I had a Western Digital Caviar Green, it "died", I plugged it into another computer and it has worked flawless ever since. Before all of those drive I did have some "questionable" WD2500s which seems to fail when I used the hostRAID which is nforce based.

link|improve this question
76% accept rate
Please provide us more details. How did the hard drives die? How many? Were the drives the same age, or were some new? – Breakthrough Aug 22 '11 at 17:41
You can always just get a new controller card for it and not use the on-board SATA. I know it doesn't actually confirm or deny a problem with the board, but it is a simple and relatively cheap work around if you still want to use the board. – MaQleod Aug 22 '11 at 17:43
@MaQleod Normally that is what I would do, I have another mobo. The reason I am want to bring this back from the dead is it has 6 SATA ports. I am working on a homebrew iSCSI target for a project and I need exactly 6 ports. – Solignis Aug 22 '11 at 17:47
That Seagate 7200.11 may have only been partially dead: sites.google.com/site/seagatefix/Home – Mark Johnson Dec 11 '11 at 3:09
feedback

1 Answer

up vote 0 down vote accepted

Unfortunately, such testing devices for SATA ports are very expensive and I have not seen a home/small scale solution to this other than to plug in a device and see if it works.

How many devices have actually died? If it is 1 or 2, you could just be very unlucky - if it is 3-4 of a single brand/model, it could be a flaw/problem in that model (There have been various problems/ranges of dead drives in recent years). If however it is 4+ of different brands, I fear that you may be correct.

One test I would do is to plug in a SATA optical drive and see if you get the same problems after a while.

In addition, I have not heard of the vendor "eVGA", so, I really can't comment on their quality, but, I have seen with some motherboards (most recently with Gigabyte) that when AHCI mode is turned on, under some circumstances, if there is a power failure or reboot where the hard drive does not fully shut down, it will completely act dead even when it isn't. The only solution I was able to find was to place the drive in another machine, 0 level format it and put it back in the machine.

You may want to double check this - Gigabyte is usually a good brand and I was able to replicate this error on quite a few different motherboards, therefore, I assume this is more I/O chipset related and it may be shared across other manufacturers - unfortunately, I am not sure what the brand is, but the board was GA-P55-US3L.

If this is the same I/O Chip vendor, a solution could be to turn the hard drive AHCI mode off - this fixed (or worked around) the problem I found.

link|improve this answer
Well thats the thing, I am recalling from fuzzy memory, I know MOST of the drives that failed were Seagates. and the WD Green that I had, failed in the machine but the integrity of the drive was fine. So maybe it was just the Seagate drive were bad luck. Considering the M/B showed signs when running windows, is a stretch to think that maybe it was related to drivers? I would running Linux now. – Solignis Aug 22 '11 at 17:59
Would an enterprise scale IT department have such a device? If not, who would besides chip manufacturers? Maybe OP would have access to one that way? – Yitzchak Aug 22 '11 at 18:39
@Solignis - It depends where the failure was - Did you install Intel Rapid Storage or a similar utility just before the failure? It really depends on the situation and you have not given enough information e.g. does it fail during Windows (Bluescreen/similar) in which case, I think the problem is something else completely, or is it failing pre OS/not visible in the BIOS - if so, Windows/Linux will have same problem. – William Hilsum Aug 22 '11 at 21:10
@Yitzchak It is very expensive, I only know manufacturers/re-manufacturers with the equipment. Most Support companies do as I said and just try a spare optical/hard drive to test. – William Hilsum Aug 22 '11 at 21:10
feedback

Your Answer

 
or
required, but never shown
discard

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.