Take the 2-minute tour ×
Super User is a question and answer site for computer enthusiasts and power users. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Long time ago, during the days I own my first computer in 2001, I heard that scratched CD/DVD can harm to the laser head of the DVD drives.

Is it true? Is it even true for today's DVD drives? I've bought my current DVD drive this July. Can I run scratched optical discs multiple times without causing harm to the drive's head?

share|improve this question
add comment

2 Answers 2

up vote 4 down vote accepted

A CD laser head has a working distance of 2.1mm, the mechanism maintains this distance dynamically in order to keep the laser beam focussed on the reflective layer in the disk. Unless your scratched CD has scratches deeper than a millimetre or ploughed ridges greater than a millimetre it is unlikely that there will be physical contact.

My Kill Bill volume 1 is 1.2 mm thick, this is typical for optical disks. So I suspect it would be hard to gouge the disk sufficiently to cause problems and still have something that you'd have any reason to put into your DVD drive.

share|improve this answer
add comment

Once the scratches are less than the working distance mentioned by RedGrittyBrick it should pose no physical problems to the laser or eye.

Reading a minimaly scratched disc is ok, the builtin error correction easily handles this. But reading a severly scratched disc can cause the laser to move excessively back and forth re-reading the area of the scratch. You can hear the movement of the eye as it moves back and forth when it attampts to read a severly scratched paort of the disc. If the disc is really bad and after a few seconds to minues of re-reading, the drive will report an error for that sector(s). It is up to the application to report an error to the user or to continue to the next sector. For movie discs (in most players), the next sector is read and the image is partially reconstructed. That is why you may get some artifacts in your movie for a split second. Data discs on the other hand, will pose a problem. Similar to a bad sector on your HD that piece of data is "unrecoverable".

Now comes the tricky part. You can attempt to recover the bad sector by reading the area over and over. How can this work? Unlike a bad sector on your HD, a scratch is a surface defect. The data is most likely intact on the recorded surface. Reading over with the laser can get by some of the scratches to the data. Once enough data us recovered, error recovery does the rest.

And finally this excessive reading over and over will wear down the drive motors causing the drive to malfuntion. It may not burn as well or read data as well as before.

All of this is from my experience of performing data recovery on optical media. The drives do fail much faster than simply burning or reading good discs. Interesting enough a firmware update to the drive can prolong its life until it starts to malfunction again.

My recommendations, if you are just burning/reading discs your drive should last a while. For data recovery, expect to repalce your drive much earlier. Store and handle your discs properly to prevent scratches.

Other advice, when burning, make sure to verify. Optical media do decay over time so I suggest you verify your data after a few years. Use error recovery generation software (quickpar) to generate recovery data to in the event you do meet an error, it can be recovered.

Hope this helps, Naresh

share|improve this answer
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.