Super User is a question and answer site for computer enthusiasts and power users. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

I want to put a NAS drive at a relative's house to serve as my offsite backup. Can you suggest a solution:

  • Not too expensive
  • Minimum 1TB of storage
  • NAS must be stand-alone: no help from router except port-forwarding (i.e. VPN is not an option), no help from a PC on the local network
  • NAS is mountable in Windows 7 via a secure method

The last requirement I am willing to bend a bit: it would be nice to have drive letter access, so I can use the backup software of my choice (and have more flexibility with the storage in general), but if there is a turn-key product out there that would be able to accomplish this solely for backup, I would consider it.

share|improve this question
Shopping related questions are not allowed here, please adjust your question... However, I will try to give a generic answer without recommending a specific product. – William Hilsum Oct 9 '11 at 16:55
Tried to modify a bit :/ Hope you don't mind! I like my answer and think this could be a good question if not specifically shopping related. – William Hilsum Oct 9 '11 at 17:20
Not at all, thanks! – actp Oct 9 '11 at 19:35
I discovered that some consumer backup NAS products have moddable Linux on them, and its possible to install scp or vsftpd, among others, and there are several solutions to access these protocols from windows. I am going to attempt this! – actp Oct 9 '11 at 19:51
Good luck, but, read a lot of reviews first and be very careful! – William Hilsum Oct 9 '11 at 19:54

I am not aware of American pricing/products available, and can not really recommend as shopping questions are not allowed here, but I will give some generic advice.

Cheap NAS units are usually not very good and have very slow transfer speeds - that being said, unless your friend has a cable/fibre connection, even cheap NAS units will most likely be faster than the speed of the connection.

All this being said, typically the cheaper NAS units are very limited on protocols. It will most likely support SMB/Samba, but, opening these ports up across the internet is asking for trouble and is a very bad idea.

I think without a VPN/similar, you are going to be really stuck for "mountable".

You can map and do a bit with FTP, but standard FTP security is debatable. As long as you trust your friend (after all, you are leaving your files there - unless you are also wanting to encrypt the NAS).... this should work fine.

If you do not like standard FTP, I am not sure Windows natively supports SFTP and if it does, a low end NAS unit is unlikely to support it.

All this being said, on a low budget, quite frankly, the best thing you can probably do is use an old computer or even better, buy an atom based board and a drive and load on Windows Server if you have a license (spare or through a program such as dreamspark e.t.c), then set up VPN (follow my guide). Then, you can just natively use Windows File Sharing - initial setup simplicity is debatable, but, this will be the most secure and best solution in my books.

I know you said no to VPN, but, I assume this is because you do not want to make changes to your friend's network or buy an additional box. If however you are willing to forward some ports, what difference does it make if you instead of the sharing ports, you forward the VPN ports to this box. The VPN ports will be all you need to do.

If you can find a NAS unit that has both Samba and VPN, then, you can cut off Windows Server all together, but, I do not know of such a device. Similarly, you can most likely use Linux instead of Windows Server in the above example, but, I don't know where to get started there.

Hope this helps your!

share|improve this answer
On forwarding VPN ports, what hardware would be running the VPN? I would need a router that can run a VPN, correct? – actp Oct 9 '11 at 19:38
@actp not at all - If as in my solution you ran a Windows Server on a small box, it can run a VPN server out of the box very easily - you would only need to forward UDP port 500 for IPsec and TCP port 1723 for PPTP. You can do similar VPN on Linux boxes, I just can't really guide/suggest anything. – William Hilsum Oct 9 '11 at 19:42
You can also VPN using Windows Professional. XP, Vista, and 7 allowed incoming connections using PPTP. – surfasb Oct 10 '11 at 2:31

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .