Take the 2-minute tour ×
Super User is a question and answer site for computer enthusiasts and power users. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I have a DLink 601 router with several Ethernet ports on it. It runs my MacBook and Wi-Fi radio wirelessly and my iMAc is plugged into it. It has a long Ethernet cable going to my AV system in another room, with 3 components there having Ethernet connections. Can I put a simple splitter on the incoming Ethernet modem from Comcast to hook up my iMAc directly, and then safely move my router from my office to my AV room and run 3 Ethernet cables to my 3 components there? This would be instead of getting a hub or switch at the AV system. (I'm also thinking my iMAc would work even better online hooked up directly instead of going thru the router.) I'll only be using one Internet connection at a time on the three components.

share|improve this question
    
What do you mean by simple splitter, can you post a link to an example? –  dsolimano Jan 17 '12 at 21:16
    
An Ethernet splitter allows you to run two 10/100 Ethernet links over a single 4-pair line. They have to be used in pairs, one at each end. (Or, theoretically, connect to a device specifically intended to carry two connections over a single port.) –  David Schwartz Jan 17 '12 at 21:28
    
@DavidSchwartz And further down the Google results is this, which I tend to agree with: askville.amazon.com/… "NO - putting a splitter on an ethernet line will result with two devices on the same port and all kinds of hell will break loose from a network perspective." –  Iszi Jan 17 '12 at 21:31
    
@Iszi That comment sounds like it was written by someone who doesn't understand how an Ethernet splitter is wired. The wiring is not straight through. –  David Schwartz Jan 17 '12 at 21:36

2 Answers 2

For TCP/IP over Ethernet networking, there is no such thing as a "simple splitter" a-la Y-connector. There are hubs, and there are switches.

Hubs and switches are both used to interconnect multiple devices. The key difference is that hubs broadcast all data to all ports, while switches only send data to the port belonging to its recipient.

At a higher level, we have routers. Routers are used to interconnect different networks - such as your home LAN and the Internet.

At the edge of the home network, we have a network bridge. This is to connect networks which use two different physical media - like coax and Ethernet. For you, this would be your cable modem.

Sometimes, devices will have multiple capabilities bundled into one. Your D-Link 601 can perform routing and switching functions, as well as be a wireless-to-ethernet bridge. Some cable modems also come with these features, but my guess (based on your question here) is that yours doesn't.

In order to serve a single Internet connection to multiple devices in your house, a router must be the first device connected to (or included in) your bridge device (AKA cable modem).

Home Networking 101 being covered above, the bottom line here is you cannot solve your problem without at least purchasing a switch for the network. The simplest solution would be to get a switch and put it in your AV room, then be done with it.

More complicated solutions involve replacing your D-Link with a new router, and re-purposing the D-Link to be that switch. Or, you could replace your entire cable modem with one that also does routing & switching and then move the router to be your switch.

Perhaps the least preferable (depending on how you like your network to be laid out) is to just run three really long cables all the way from your AV room to the D-Link, provided that you've got the spare ports open.

share|improve this answer

No. You can't additional devices to the WAN side of your network because your Internet connection can only support a single device. That's why you need the router -- to make multiple devices (on the LAN side) appear as a single device to the modem.

You can add a switch to the LAN side of your router. Leave your router where it is. Connect the long cable to one of its LAN ports. And then get a cheap Ethernet switch (10/100, 5 ports unmanaged is fine) to connect the long cable to your other device.

Ethernet splitters allow you to run two distinct 10/100 Ethernet connections over a single cable. But you have to actually have two connections (on each side!) to do that.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.