Crontab deleted?

Question

Instead of typing "crontab -e" I accidentally typed "crontab" and was stuck in the middle of a process so I aborted the process. Now when I go to crontab -e it's entirely blank. This isn't good at all. If I can't get it back I will need to rewrite it.

Is there any way to:

1. get my crontab jobs back? are they in memory somewhere? Where are the account specific crontab files located in linux? OR
2. get a log of all things that cron has done, so I can reverse engineer my crontab file. I hadn't looked at it in a long time?

Answer 1

crontab with no arguments reads a crontab file from standard input. For example, you might use:

 echo "* * * * *  run-this-every-minute" | crontab

Once you've clobbered your crontab (i.e., crontab -l shows nothing), there's no good way to get it back.

On my system (Ubuntu 11.04), personal crontabs are stored in /var/spool/cron/crontabs/<USER> -- but that's what you clobbered, so that won't do you any good. (The path could be different on your system.)

I see entries in /var/log/syslog for commands executed by cron; you might be able to reconstruct your crontab from that (or your system's equivalent, if any), but it's going to be tedious.

Here's what I do to avoid this kind of problem:

I keep my crontab in a separate file, maintained in a source control system. I install it only by running

crontab filename

I never use crontab -e. If I accidentally clobber my crontab, I can just reload it from the file.

Oh, and this is really a question for superuser; I've voted to migrate it.

Answer 2

If your EDITOR envrionment variable is EDITOR=vi, try

vi -r

to recover the session. Do not directly write the saved session, if you get one, to your crontab directory. Use it as a guide to recreate your crontab using

crontab -e

Note: Since you did not specify an OS, Solaris and other UNIX OSes do not recognize changes to crontab files except those created through crontab -e. If I remember correctly, Linux does.

Answer 3

I'm sorry, but I can't help asking the obvious: why not restore it from backup?

Er, sorry, I see that was suggested already.