Take the 2-minute tour ×
Super User is a question and answer site for computer enthusiasts and power users. It's 100% free, no registration required.

When Win 7 went RTM, I upgraded my laptop from XP. But to protect myself against the possibility of having data inaccessible, I got a new disk and put it in the laptop, and took the old (XP) disk and put it in a USB enclosure.

I have no trouble accessing the data on the USB drive under Windows 7. But I would like to be able to plug it in, tell the BIOS to boot from the USB drive, and be back on my old machine. The laptop is a Dell Precision M90, and it has a boot from USB option in its boot menu. But when I try to do that, it does read the drive, gets as far as putting up the Windows XP splash screen and starting the boot progress bar, and then reboots.

What do I need to do to the old disk now running on USB to allow the machine to boot from it?

share|improve this question

4 Answers 4

Startup in Safe Mode with boot logging and see if you can identify where Windows fails in booting. You may then refer to the Ntbtlog.txt log file generated in the system root on the external hard drive to further diagnose the problem.

share|improve this answer
    
Thanks. I'll try that and see where it gets me. –  daveh551 Sep 9 '09 at 21:15

Pop in your XP CD and do a repair installation (see below), with the USB device connected and set as the active boot device. Where you have swapped from an IDE/AHCI connection to a USB connection, Windows may have got into a twist.

  1. When the Press any key to boot from CD message is displayed on your screen, press a key to start your computer from the Windows XP CD.
  2. Press Enter when you see the message To setup Windows XP now, and then press Enter displayed on the Welcome to Setup screen.
  3. Do not choose the option to press R to use the Recovery Console.
  4. In the Windows XP Licensing Agreement, press F8 to agree to the license agreement.
  5. Make sure that your current installation of Windows XP is selected in the box, and then press R to repair Windows XP.
  6. Follow the instructions on the screen to complete Setup.

I have seen the infinite boot-cycle problem before and the repair installation has usually fixed it.

EDIT - Your next step could be to try FIXBOOT and then FIXMBR in that order from the Recovery Console, after booting into your XP CD again. I would definitely ensure your Windows 7 disk is disconnected for this step. If you are still then unable to boot into XP from your USB-connected XP disk, see if you then have the option to do the repair installation.

share|improve this answer
    
maybe he need to remove his windows7-installed drive. –  Revolter Sep 9 '09 at 22:00
    
This is a good idea, and I have solved similar problems in Windows 7 this way, but in the XP installation disk, there is no 'R' option. Once you press F8 to accept the license, it gives you the option of ENTER to install on the selected partition, D to delete the selected partition, of F3 to quit. I even tried typing 'R' anyway, but it was ignored. Pressing ENTER to go on to the installation gives you the option of L to delete the existing \WINDOWS folder, or ESC to choose a new one, and again, there is no 'R', and pressing it didn't do anything. Can you use the Repair option on a Win7 disk? –  daveh551 Sep 9 '09 at 23:19
    
Unfortunately Windows 7 doesn't come with a "repair installation" feature like XP (which sucks). It only comes with a startup repair option (which also sucks), which would not help fixing booting into the XP installation. Hmm... –  Kez Sep 9 '09 at 23:44
    
Updated my answer –  Kez Sep 10 '09 at 0:07
    
Interesting - I just tried your original procedure with a different USB drive (this one had originally been the boot drive in my desktop, so has different drivers, etc, but I can afford to lose it.) But now the 'R' option DID come up after pressing F8. Trying to figure out what the difference is. –  daveh551 Sep 10 '09 at 1:19

If creating a bootable USB drive with Windows only were as easy as drive cloning or a repair installation.

Windows is not designed to boot and run from USB.

I wouldn't say it is entirely impossible but it certainly is a tough enough task to do a fresh (fully fledged, not BartPE) Windows installation onto a USB drive.

Over at eeeuser.com we have a decent wiki, that'll keep you busy for a day or two, at least you'll get an idea what is involved in the process.

Windows XP Professional Installation Onto SD or SDHC card

Replace 'SD or SDHC card' with your external USB drive and have fun. Keep in mind that this was written specifically for the Eee PC so you'll have to change certain settings to your requirements.

share|improve this answer

You need to make that USB disk bootable, see "How To Boot From A USB Flash Drive".

This show how to make the disk bootable, I don't know if you can boot the OS.

share|improve this answer
1  
That would make sense, except that the drive already is bootable when I removed it from the machine. It was the C:\ drive from my XP installation. –  daveh551 Sep 9 '09 at 23:38

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.