Take the 2-minute tour ×
Super User is a question and answer site for computer enthusiasts and power users. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Two questions:

  1. Can one memory module be better than the other, if both are at the same speed (667 MHz) and both are DDR2?
    I'm asking this because I found two modules with identical specifications, but one cost $40 while the other costs $160.

  2. Is all RAM compatible with Mac?
    My iMac accepts, DDR2 SDRAM at 667 MHz. Does this mean that ALL desktop DDR2 SDRAM at 667 MHz would work with my iMac? Or do Macs specifically have some kind of additional requirement? (i.e. "Mac compatibility")

share|improve this question
    
Why was this downvoted? –  user117094 Mar 14 '12 at 22:45
    
Pondering this a few years ago, I decided to pull the RAM from my mac and check the part number. I found identical RAM on ebay (searching for the part number(s)) which was not marked in any way as mac, so I guess it was 'pc ram'. Got it for $32 when it was like $150 at the mac store. Worked like a charm. But not all RAMs are compatible with all boards, which is why I opted for an identical part number (didn't know all the stuff I do now about computer architecture back then). The price discrepancies you notice may also be based on availabilty vs # of machines that require it still in use. –  conspiritech Mar 18 '12 at 14:23
add comment

2 Answers

  1. There are several features that can distinguish two memory modules with the same clock speed. As Patrick mentioned, they can have different latencies. CAS latency is the number of cycles it takes from the time the CPU requests a certain memory address to the time that data is available at the memory module's pins, and is specified either as a single digit (e.g., CL=5) or as a series of digits separated by hyphens (e.g., CL=5-5-5-15 ). In the latter case, the digits refer to a set of delays. Memory addresses are laid out as rows and columns. CAS stands for Column Address Strobe, but there are also delays for Row address to Column address Delay (RCD), Row Precharge (RP), and Row Address Strobe (RAS). The details are beyond the scope of this question, but there is a nice Wikipedia article with a more in-depth explanation along with a nice table illustrating how the numbers are related.

    But that's not the only difference. Server- or workstation-grade DIMMs usually come with buffers and/or error-correction. These are called Registered (aka Buffered) memory and ECC memory, respectively, and a DIMM can have one, both, or neither of these features. These types of modules often won't even work in consumer-grade desktop computers, and if they do work, the features are usually disabled. For a consumer-grade desktop computer, you should always look for Unbuffered memory modules.

    There are also other reasons why one module may be more expensive--for example, it might have one or more (primarily cosmetic) additional features, such as a heatsink, fan kit, or even blinking LEDs.

    Lastly, certain brands have gained reputations for reliability and compatibility (both with the computer and with other memory modules), whereas others have higher reported failure rates and more stability or compatibility complaints. I spent many years only buying certain brands of memory, but over the past few years I've started using other brands on occasion. Unfortunately, 3 out of the 5 other brands I've tried have had reliability problems, often passing an initial thorough memory diagnostic but failing more than a year later. It's true that most memory comes with a lifetime warranty, but the hassle of having to diagnose random crashes and later having to buy more memory to use during the replacement process is something you may want to consider.

  2. In addition to reported timing-related issues, some Macs require low-profile DIMMs which are physically not as tall as other DIMMs. For these models, the taller DIMMs won't fit in the available space. For this reason alone, you should check for Mac compatibility, or at least double-check the physical dimensions of the memory. Given two modules with similar prices, I'd go with the one that is either labeled Mac-compatible or for which another Mac owner has left a positive review. If there is a huge price difference, I'd probably try the cheaper one as long as I could return it.

share|improve this answer
    
Just out of curiosity, could you explain the hyphenated version of the CAS latency notation? –  Oliver Salzburg Mar 17 '12 at 20:01
1  
Sure--they actually refer to a set of latencies. Memory addresses are laid out as rows and columns. CAS stands for Column Address Strobe, but there are also delays for RAS to CAS Delay (RCD), RAS Precharge (RP), and Row Address Strobe (RAS). Here is a more in-depth explanation along with a nice table illustrating how the numbers are related: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SDRAM_latency –  rob Mar 17 '12 at 20:22
add comment

RAM modules with otherwise similar specs could have different CAS latencies. All else being equal, a module with a lower CAS Latency (sometimes listed as CL) would cost more because it is faster.

Not all memory is Mac compatible. I have seen MacBook Pros that needed CL values of 8 to 10. Anything higher or lower caused kernel panics. You should find the CAS Latency of the RAM that came with the given Mac, and buy memory with that latency or higher. Apple generally supplies machines with the lowest latency (i.e., fastest) memory supported by that model Mac.

share|improve this answer
1  
Also important that some memory comes with additions like heatsinks that make them more expensive. –  Ziv Mar 17 '12 at 17:57
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.