We have an externally-accessible subnet on which all our desktops and a few servers sit. Due to a lack of IPs, we put the servers (which don't need to be externally accessible) on a private subnet and our firewall simply routes between the two subnets and NATs if a machine on the private subnet needs to get out to the internet. (Not an ideal setup but the easiest to implement without a lot of upheaval)
One of the servers (a VM host) is currently configured on the private subnet and all works fine. We need to have the server accessible from outside so I tried to add an interface to the VM so that the server would have an interface on the private subnet and another interface on the main, external subnet.
Upon bringing up the second interface, the machine stops responding to pings on the first interface that originate from the main subnet. This happens on the server (CentOS) and the test Ubuntu VM I also tried it with.
Are there any kernel settings that might cause this? If a machine has one interface on 10.0.0.1/8 and another on 188.8.131.52/24, would it refuse to respond to a ping from 184.108.40.206 if it arrived on the 10.0.0.1 interface? I've checked and it's receiving the ping but not responding on either interface..