vote up 1 vote down star

I am a Mac user and as such not very knowledgeable about the desktop and laptop Windows world. But since Apple are not going ahead with a Mac netbook, I think I should get a Windows netbook.

This is where my pitiful ignorance comes in.

Can anyone recommend a netbook with the following features:

  1. Runs Windows 7.
  2. Has at least 2 GB of RAM.
  3. Hard disk or solid state, solid state preferred.
  4. Can use external USB DVD drive.
  5. Can use (and boot from) external USB hard drive.
  6. Preferably has 3G modem and sim card slot built-in.
  7. Should be available in Ireland somehow (can order from UK or Europe).
  8. CPU can be 32 bit or 64 bit but must have VT-x support.
  9. Price is secondary (technically 9th) concern.

Any recommendations?

flag
2  
From your features, it sounds more like a regular laptop than a netbook to me ;) – Gnoupi Nov 12 at 10:46
1  
Consider making your question community wiki; I don't think there's a single answer. – alex Nov 12 at 11:09
Gn: No. Already have a MacBook. Has to be smaller. al: Done. – Andrew J. Brehm Nov 12 at 11:39
@Andrew: your features are a bit "too much", for a netbook, this is what I meant. Also, this question is really subjective and argumentative and looking at the answers and comments confirms this impression. "i hate this brand", "hmm, too big". If you want objective recommendations, based on a list of precise features, ok. But keep it objective, or add restrictions to your features, to not lead to a discussion. – Gnoupi Nov 12 at 12:07
2  
you do realize that the Vaio P 8" display with a resolution of 1600x768 is a joke, no matter how much you crank up the DPI settings. :) don't just order from somewhere, go find a real one and have a LOOK at it first. although i wouldn't know of any shops on our lovely island selling them. – Molly Nov 13 at 2:16
show 1 more comment

6 Answers

vote up 1 vote down check

You can go for an HP netbook, from the Mini series. They usually have good reviews, the build quality is OK and, best of all, they make great hackintoshes. I can't recommend you a model; the decision should be yours. You know best what you want.

link|flag
1  
And that's exactly what I got. The Mini series is very good. – Andrew J. Brehm Dec 27 at 1:23
Glad to know I could be of help. – alex Dec 27 at 8:37
vote up 1 vote down

You'll look pretty hard to find both SSD and Win7. I'm told a (full, normal) Win7 install runs about 20GB. Add your favorite bulky apps and part of your MP3 collection and you're up to 40GB in the first week. Netbook installs come in doubtless below that mark, but still, you might find yourself squished with a stock SSD. Most netbook mfgrs have gone (back) to old-school spinning drives just so they could offer reasonable capacity at a price people will pay. If you really want SSD, you might have to go aftermarket (to Intel, say).

I have no specific laptop model recommendations, but the rest of your requirements sound reasonable enough. You might enjoy reading the reviews at RegHardware, which are excellent, and also oriented especially to the UK/Eire markets. Here is their Netbook buying guide. It's likely a little too old for the specs you're looking for, but it's a good entree into their site. Or have a look at their review of the Dell Latitude 2100, just for starters. Plus, like many UK/Irish Dells, it's probably assembled right there in Ireland.

And note as you look that it's the following Intel Atom chips that support VT-X (which the above mentioned Dell Netbook does not have!):

Atom Z520, Z530, Z540, Z550 (Silverthorne)

Source, Wikipedia.

link|flag
I hate Dell. :-( – Andrew J. Brehm Nov 12 at 11:40
vote up 1 vote down

I believe the Sony VAIO X series fits your list.

http://www.sony.ie/product/vnp-x-series


If you want smaller, the Sony VAIO P series also fits your list.

http://www.sony.ie/product/vnp-p-series/vgn-p39vl-q

link|flag
Seems a bit big. – Andrew J. Brehm Nov 12 at 11:43
VAOI P: This seems EXACTLY like what I want. Having a look now... – Andrew J. Brehm Nov 12 at 13:00
They don't make it easy to buy the thing, do they? I cannot find any reference to the P series in Sony's online store. – Andrew J. Brehm Nov 12 at 13:07
vote up 1 vote down

here's exactly what you're looking for:

Sony Vaio VPCX11Z1E/X (available from Sony UK and any reseller)

alt text

11.1" WXGA display 1366x768

Intel® Atom™ Processor Z550 (2.0 GHz, 64-bit, VT-x support)

2 GB RAM

256 GB Solid State Disk

7.2Mbps (HSDPA/HSUPA, UMTS, EDGE, GPRS) modem built-in

Windows 7 Prodessional

there's a lower spec model available, the VPCX11S1E/B with Atom Z540 (1.86 GHz) and 128 MB SSD.

link|flag
Looks good but Sony make it very difficult to see a price and links to online stores are also well-hidden. Do they not want me to buy this? – Andrew J. Brehm Nov 12 at 13:52
Can't find it in the online store. There seem to be two worlds, one with a Sony online store and one where Sony products cannot be bought. Like the P series this model appears to exist only in the latter world. :-( – Andrew J. Brehm Nov 12 at 13:56
elara.ie have them, here's the little one (just shy of 1500 euro :) elara.ie/products/… – Molly Nov 12 at 15:04
vote up 0 vote down

Why don't you go with a HM pavilion DV3? It got a faster CPU and better graphics than a standard netbook. There are similar systems "slim and light" from other vendors available, too. (ACER, Packard Bell etc.)

link|flag
The HP Mini 311 looks good. It also has a sim card slot. hp.com/united-states/campaigns/mini1000/… – Andrew J. Brehm Nov 12 at 11:46
The HP Mini 311 doesn't support VT-x. – Joseph Nov 12 at 11:52
Too big... Once the screen reaches 11" I am back at MacBook level... – Andrew J. Brehm Nov 12 at 11:53
vote up -1 vote down

OMG do not and I say do not buy an HP. Earlier this year they had big problems with laptops and desktops and ended up with two lawsuits alledging that they deliberately sold inherently defective mobos. I should know since I bought their top of the line desktop with many upgrades this past October and spent a lot of money and fought for two months to get replacement mobo. At the time they sold it to me they already knew the mobos were bad and were having Asus subsiderary remake the mobo but it took awhile and HP implemented all sorts of stall tactics. They lied over and over to their customers. Unbelieveable. I would never and mean never trust this bunch again. There are thousands of posts about how bad it was. Look under Hangs, Freezes and Lockups on their forums. What a nightmare! Also they have this bogus return policy, you can only return it after 21 days. It takes several days for them to build it and then several days to ship it so you will be lucky to have it for one week before warranty expires to figure out any and all issues. Also they will send you to India tech support which is a nightmare in itself and that also can delay you big time. Many folks spent many hours with their tech support with no resolution and it is another way they can run the clock out on your warranty. Don't take my word for it...google for yourself.

link|flag
1  
I already bought the HP and I am very happy with it. My experience with HP computers was always positive. At work we use their servers. I ordered the Mini from HP's online store and received it within two days. I also own a (useless) HP PDA I bought a few years ago. – Andrew J. Brehm Dec 27 at 1:22

Your Answer

Get an OpenID
or
never shown

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.