up vote 1 down vote favorite
share [g+] share [fb]

As the number of computers at my home increases (now up to 3 in active use, and expected to rise in the following years), I start longing for a central storage unit, so that I don't have to keep the computers on all the time. So a network hard drive would satisfy this basic need. The first question thus is:

Can you recommend/dis-recommend a network hard drive model/manufacturer?

However I'm a programmer (read: geek), so I'd like to squeeze the juice out of this piece of hardware. It would be really nice if it could also serve files over the Internet via FTP or (recommended) SCP. For complete satisfaction it would also have to be able to run basic apache/php/mysql for a small home website. Maybe even an SVN server. Nothing too demanding as this will be strictly for my own private use, but still. Thus the second question:

Will a network HDD have enough power in it to do this? Will there not be too little CPU/RAM? Perhaps there is something else that serves this need better?

A few more notes:

  • Has to support Windows shares. All my machines are Windows machines and I want to use the storage unit transparently on them.
  • Quietness/size is a major factor for this device. Ideally I want it tiny and fanless (but at least with 1TB of storage). The sound of a standard 3.5" 7200rpm HDD is OK. I don't want SSD as that would be clearly outside my financial reach.
  • I do not need any video output. I don't own a TV and don't plan on getting one. The machine will be strictly network-accessed.
  • I have not yet decided on a budget for the device because I have no idea how much these things cost. But keep it reasonable. $2000 is waaay too much.
link|improve this question

64% accept rate
feedback

4 Answers

up vote 2 down vote accepted

an atom based minu itx system is cheap and good enough - most have at least 2 sata ports and one IDE one, a full range of basic ports, and tends to be cheap- pop one into a standard case (mini itx cases are over priced), add a 1 tb hard drive, and you're good. OS wise, freenas will do quite well

link|improve this answer
I'm looking at that now. Seems like that would be about 2x more expensive than a NAS, but the difference in power would be noticeable. But it could be made fanless with fairly standard components. – Vilx- Nov 13 '09 at 13:07
feedback

I quite like the Drobo. You can network enable it with the Drobo Share

Drobo

link|improve this answer
Looks good if what you need is massive storage with redundancy. In my case though it's not exactly what I want, plus it's a bit beyond my wallet size. Other than that I like the idea. Maybe I will find use for it in the future. – Vilx- Nov 13 '09 at 11:37
Did wonder about the cost as they are not the cheapest – Xetius Nov 13 '09 at 12:16
feedback

I had the same problem and I decided upon having fan-less computer (Alix 1D) with FreeNAS. I added to that 2.5" HD and result is practically noiseless storage. Total cost was around $250 for Alix and $100 for HD. For backup I use another HD in external case.

link|improve this answer
Is the CPU/RAM enough to run apache/php/mysql? – Vilx- Nov 13 '09 at 10:22
I am afraid not. :( – Josip Medved Nov 13 '09 at 11:03
MySQL and SVN would need another machine... – Josip Medved Nov 13 '09 at 11:04
In that case I might as well go for a simple network hdd. – Vilx- Nov 13 '09 at 11:38
feedback

Netgear, HP and many other brands make a great home networking server. I recommend what I currently am using and that is the HP MediaSmart Server EX485 it works great, I have scheduled automatic backups for all of my home computers and laptops, and I also can ftp to it from my office at work.

alt text

link|improve this answer
Looks big and noisy. I don't want another PC-like machine at home. I want something tiny and quiet that I can put in a corner and forget where it is. – Vilx- Nov 13 '09 at 10:21
It's very quiet and small – AskaGamer Nov 13 '09 at 19:27
feedback

Your Answer

 
or
required, but never shown

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.