Take the 2-minute tour ×
Super User is a question and answer site for computer enthusiasts and power users. It's 100% free, no registration required.

If I want to know what my options are for a Linux program then I'll do man program or program --help to find out. How do you do that on Windows?

I was reading about how to run a screensaver from the command line and I found out about this file:

%SYSTEMROOT%\system32\scrnsave.scr

When called directly, the settings page for that screensaver is launched instead of the actual screensaver.

I tried help scrnsave.scr and scrnsave.scr /? and more, but nothing worked. It wasn't until I tried google that I found the command line options in the middle of a MSDN article and knew I had to use:

%SYSTEMROOT%\system32\scrnsave.scr /s

How was I supposed to know about the /s option? What is the correct way to find program options in the Windows command line?

share|improve this question

2 Answers 2

up vote 2 down vote accepted

There isn't a correct way. But there isn't on Unix, either. The --help convention is in fact a GNU convention. It's widespread on Linux distributions, where the operating system utilities are GNU ones. But you won't see it in the operating system utilities on a BSD, for example:

$ /bin/sh --help
Illegal option --
$ nawk --help
nawk: no program given

$

Much as the --help convention has been seen by many as a good idea, and adopted; the /? convention (which originated in DR-DOS 5.0 as a /H convention) has been seen by many as a good idea, and adopted. You'll find that many commands support it. But equally as not all commands in Unix or Linux support --help not all commands in DOS or Windows NT support /?.

You might think that man comes to the rescue here. Thanks to GNU info, and the fact that several program maintainers seem to place information (even sometimes information as basic as what the command-line options are) only in the info page and not in the man page or vice versa, it's not the panacaea that it might be thought to be, however.

man doesn't really have an equivalent in the DOS and Windows NT world. The closest equivalent was helpcommand, which in DR-DOS 5.0 and later and MS-DOS 6.0 and later would look up command in a database of help pages and display the page. The problem here is that whilst all of the operating system's own housekeeping utilities had pages in this database, almost no-one else's programs did, and the system was hard to add third-party information to.

(DOSBook, introduced in DR-DOS 6.0 was about the best that any commercial DOS got with this. MS-DOS used QuickHelp files, the tool for compiling which wasn't supplied with the base operating system. PC-DOS 7 had the IPF system, a tool for compiling which again was lacking from the operating system. OS/2 had the same IPF system as PC-DOS, and a HELP command that was integrated with it, although again the compiler, IPFC, was in the Developers Toolkit rather than in the box with the operating system. Many years ago I wrote an improvement upon the supplied HELP command where one could configure which command references it looked commands up in by default, with an environment variable. I also provided an extended command reference book for some commands that I'd written.)

Windows NT still has helpcommand to this day. It's a step backwards from what MS-DOS 6 had, let alone from what DR-DOS, PC-DOS, and OS/2 had.

So the actual answer is: You're supposed to trawl through MSDN, or read someone else's WWW site, or read a book, or read the source code (if it's open source), or just know telepathically …

That said, documentation on the WWW is not a bad thing, and is largely the expectation nowadays. (Although one can miss things like IPFC building indexes and tables of contents for one. ☺) Microsoft documents a whole raft of command-line commands on TechNet and in MSDN, as you have seen.

Further reading

share|improve this answer

For pure Windows programs, displaying help is usually /?. However, there are more and more cross-platform programs coming up and they use -?, --help or even other commands.

Actually it's not required by Windows programs to support any help output at all, so it's all up to the developer of the program.

Screensavers are a little bit special, because Microsoft has defined what a screensaver has to support. And what you found it exactly that definition Obviously Microsoft does not define any mandatory /? command line switch.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.