vote up 10 vote down star

Just this week Microsoft gives PDC attendees tweaked Acer 1420P as a model Laptop which uses the hardware as MS assumed it in Windows.

As I read from FAQ on the PDC page even retail Acer 1420P will have some special crapware to use hotkeys. Even after MS showed them how to do it correctly :-(.

Is there a laptop on the market that

  • Has all drivers on Windows DVD or Windows Update (which guarantees that they will work as MS designed it)
  • Don't install any special OEM services or applications without which you cannot use the hardware to it's full potential, but which slows down your computer, eats memory and so on.

EDIT:

  • I Like windows, I don't like linux (and belive me I've tried), I don't want to pay extra for Mac
  • I just want a windows with proper drivers

On the side note:

  • How many times I change my Graphic Card settings that I need application which i can click in a tray icon?
  • Why when I install Lenovo drivers for proper multi-monitor functionality I'm forced to install full suite of their software?
  • How many times I change my sound settings that I need tray icon application to run at start?
flag
4  
cough Macbook cough – joshhunt Nov 20 at 14:07
14  
what, and pay $500 more just for the apple logo? no thanks. – Justin Drury Nov 20 at 14:18
16  
OS X is the crappy OEM software cough cough. – regan Nov 20 at 14:50
The PDC Acer came with pre-installed crap-ware too: Corel PaintIt, Office 2010 beta, Windows Live apps, etc. – GAThrawn Nov 20 at 15:52
@GAThrawn Yes, but as I understand they are not required and can be uninstalled, while without OEM crapware usually you can't use some hardware. – SeeR Nov 20 at 18:22

12 Answers

vote up 3 vote down check

PC Pro magazine recently looked at this and came to the conclusion that only Apple don't feel the need for crapware.

I think that business machines come cleaner than home machines, so you may be better off looking at that side of things.

link|flag
vote up 25 vote down

Yes: the laptop on which you install yourself the operating system from zero.

link|flag
3  
This really is the only way to go with laptops. And even with prebuilt systems like Dells and HPs. – Justin Drury Nov 20 at 14:19
1  
Unfortunately no. For example on Lenovo I was unable to use another monitor. The only way was to install their software but of course it installed few more things which I don't needed. – SeeR Nov 20 at 14:32
1  
Sadly the only way to be sure is to nuke the entire laptop. My current HP was better than most but still had a lot of crud on. Just hope you get proper Windows installation DVD with the laptop and not a recovery disc that will just put all the crud straight back on. – Dave Webb Nov 20 at 14:34
3  
A lot of upvotes for a trite answer that, I think, doesn't actually answer his question. :) He wants a laptop which will work, including its proprietary hardware, from a standard Windows install disk. The only way the answer can be yes is if the laptop has no proprietary hardware. – JMD Nov 20 at 16:31
1  
@JMD: Or if it comes with a drivers CD. – harrymc Nov 20 at 16:57
show 1 more comment
vote up 5 vote down

I got a Dell Latitude 820 about year ago directly from Dell which had no extra software installed on it except for Windows XP. We got the machine through the small business side of Dell and not through the consumer side. It's a no frills machine, but worked quite well for what I needed it for.

Hope this helps.

link|flag
vote up 3 vote down

Find pretty much any laptop designed for the business market, eg Dell Latitudes, format and reinstall the OS from a clean Windows CD.

You'll now have a full working laptop that will happily do everything 90% of people want from it. Drivers for obscure/unusual hardware will be missing, but very few of them will actually have any effect on day to day web browsing, email and word processing.

If you're still missing functionality, go to the manufacturer's website, download the relevant driver. Extract the driver package, but don't install it. Find the folders/files that have been extracted, there should be at least one folder, probably named after the OS, in there with files of type ".inf", ".cat" and ".sys" these are the actual drivers, most of the time everything else that's been extracted is the pointless crapware. Go into Device Manager, click Update Driver, point it at the drivers folder with those files in.

You should now be up to about 95% functionality, and what you're left with are the very niche stuff that absolutely needs apps installed. This will be things like the advanced capabilities of your graphics cards, totally unusual hardware that doesn't have windows APIs yet (like fingerprint readers), dialler apps for 3G dongles (though often you can set up and use these as if they're an old fashioned modem connection, if you can find out the initiation strings and APN details) and so on.

link|flag
vote up 1 vote down

Has all drivers on Windows DVD or Windows Update (which guarantees that they will work as MS designed it)

Don't install any special OEM services or applications without which you cannot use the hardware to it's full potential, but which slows down your computer, eats memory and so on.

These are really the same question.

"Do any laptop manufacturers 'just work' on a default installation of Windows, without their special proprietary drivers and add-on software?"

The answer is no. And that's the point. The value add of buying a prebuilt, preinstalled system is that all the hardware just works. Of course, the cash cow is the upgraded hardware components (memory, disk, etc) that make the system fast enough to actually use.

If you want a laptop/notebook that doesn't have OEM crapware, you need to either:

  • Install the OS from scratch and hunt down all the manufacturer's drivers (which may not have all the features enabled).
  • Use a non-Windows operating system (Linux or OS X).

Yes, I'm sure you have many reasons to use Windows, and I'm sure they're valid for your computer usage. But the best answer to your question is to get a laptop/notebook that doesn't have the crapware to begin with.

Someone made a snarky comment that Apple's OS is the crapware on Macs. That is cute, but the reality is that the operating system is very solid, and it really doesn't have all the garbage typical of Windows laptops. Plus, you can install Windows on a second partition or use one of the various virtual machine products (VMware Fusion, Parallels, etc).

Another option is to install Linux, which certainly costs less than OS X, but has its own set of headaches, such as lack of support entirely for particular hardware.

Most people just live with the crapware on Windows. SuperUsers find an alternative solution either by installing a different OS, or building the laptop from scratch with no OS (and using a barebones OEM Windows).

link|flag
vote up 1 vote down

On a related note I find PC Decrapifier really good for streamlining the uninstallation of all the crappy OEM stuff.

link|flag
vote up 0 vote down

Dell does (at least did) sell some systems without operating systems (or rather, with a no-name version of DOS), including certain model Latitude laptops. I would suspect there are some from lenovo as well (note: these would be Linux based pre-installed OS)

link|flag
vote up 0 vote down

@jtimberman pretty much nailed it. Sadly, regarding your specific question, likely there is not a laptop on the market that has all drivers on the Windows DVD or Windows Update for the proprietary, manufacturer-specific hardware in the laptop.

Windows itself does not contain the drivers to run things like the proprietary, manufacturer-specific fingerprint scanners and sleep, rotate, lock, help, and other buttons, and for managing touch screens and screen rotation in the case of tablets. That's the reason that the custom crapware from Toshiba, or whichever other manufacturer, is required. Windows simply doesn't contain those kinds of drivers. (Yet?)

I ranted about the same thing as you, with this laptop, because the drivers and services involved were so extensive and so crappy they brought the laptop to a crawl. Windows was, for all intents and purposes, unusable. I have since nuked and paved with LinuxMint, giving up the proprietary hardware (aforementioned buttons, fingerprint scanner, and touch screen) for a usable O/S. (Granted, I may have gotten away with simply reinstalling a standard Windows installation, sans crapware.) (Also granted, it's entirely possible that some of these proprietary drivers have since been ported to Linux.)

In essence, my primary complaint is not with the fact that the proprietary drivers were required, but with their sloppy implementation via bloated user mode resident programs and services, instead of with actual system drivers (like would be installed during the Windows installation). I'm not joking when I say there were in the neighbourhood of 60+ resident programs and services running in Windows above those in a standard "desktop" installation of Windows XP.

link|flag
vote up 0 vote down

Just buy a DIY Laptop from manufacturer like Asus, MSI, Compal, OCZ, Clevo or Quanta.

Here is a website in the US where you can buy some of them.

http://www.xoticpc.com/

Try google to find more in your country.

Newegg and NCIX offers some too.

More and more are becoming availlable as barebone, so you can select your Hardware and software yourself, just like building your own desktop PC.

link|flag
vote up 0 vote down

We are selling and configuring different Fujitsu Esprimo notebooks to our customers. There is only Windows, Office 2007 Trial and Adobe Reader installed. I think you won't find less. And you get all drivers needed on a dedicated DVD plus Windows 7 and Windows XP recovery DVDs. All other crapware is on the dedicated DVD, but not installed by default. So their systems are just quite clean ;-)

link|flag
vote up 0 vote down

The Microsoft Store has some laptops that are crapwear free... try it out.

link|flag
Unfortunately they can be bought only in US :-( – SeeR Nov 23 at 7:59
vote up 0 vote down

When I bought an HP dv9700, the OEM crap was causing all kinds of system hangs and processor max-outs which neither HP or MS could fix. As a result, MS sent me shiny new 64-bit Vista discs. The only sw I had to put on was the quick launch buttons which I rarely use anyway and a driver for the remote. Computer works much better now.

Basically, it your OEN software causes errors and reliability issues, if you make a big enough stink with MS, they will help you out.

Just a suggestion that worked for me.

link|flag

Your Answer

Get an OpenID
or
never shown

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.