Is the MacBook Pro, without Mac OS X, worth it? [closed]

Question

(I posted it in Stack Overflow (http://stackoverflow.com/questions/2046421/is-the-macbook-pro-without-mac-os-x-worth-it-closed) but, as indicated, reposted here)

I have an Asus G50V-X5. It's a great notebook, better than what I need it for. For example, it has a great video card that I (almost) don't use. I only use GNU/Linux and don't like Compiz a lot. Just play some simple games, which use the Quake 3 engine. Nothing special.

I am thinking in selling this and purchasing a MacBook Pro for its battery life and smaller size, but dunno if it's worth it.

I prefer MacBook Pro's size, weight and extreme battery life. But I really dislike Apple's business decisions, and I won't be using Mac OS X.

So, thinking just in the hardware, is MacBook Pro worthy?

Answer 1

I have mixed feelings about this.

I would personally not (unless I was given one for free/very good offer) because Apple pricing, arrogance, and pretty much everything drives me mad. When you look at the components, you can get a similar specification laptop for much cheaper.

However, the pro is that, they keep their value MUCH longer, you can sell one a few years later on eBay or anywhere and get a much higher return than any other brand.

Just make sure that the distribution you end up using is fully compatible.

So, it is really up to you...

Answer 2

I admire Apple's products, as they are pretty, but it's no different than a PC since they switched to Intel. The insides are identical, but cost more. Apple marks up hardware by 100%. Unless you think the price is worth it, no.

For a teensy bit more on Apple's expensive hardware markups, please see a blog post I wrote at http://mosheberman.com/wordpress/?p=87 .

I am typing this from a MacBook that has an impressive battery life. (3-4 hours after 3 years.)

However, bear in mind that should you have an issue AND an AppleCare plan, Apple will have people to help you, unlike other companies, who outsource their tech support to people who are clueless about the systems that they support. Apple techs know their "beans".

PS: This question may be flagged as subjective... Just a hunch.

Answer 3

If You need high end notebook with Linux support You should interest in Lenovo Think Pad or Dell Precision. I have ThinkPad T61p that I love, but now I would recommend Dell because IMO new Dells look nicer then new ThinkPads (unfortunately).

You will don't waste your mony for OS X, You will have trackpoint (that I prefer over touchpad) and touchpad with 3 buttons (not one like in MacBook), and be able to replace battery, and replace CD-ROM for 2nd Hard Drive.