Should I turn off my PC when plug/unplug external display? Some people don't do that, but I think this is required to keep safe your equipment. Am I correct in thinking this?
-
1You're not correct.– Daniel R HicksApr 1, 2012 at 2:35
Add a comment
|
7 Answers
Short Answer
Assuming that this external display input is VGA, DVI, or HDMI there should be no adverse effects.
Rationalization / Support
- All of these connections are data only, so there shouldn't be any large captive or inductive loads built up on the lines.
- I have never went out of my way to shut down my PC to plug or unplug a monitor / projector in 12+ years.
- A bit more support of this would be using a KVM you remove the signal to the displays as part of normal operation. Granted that it stays plugged in at all times (see warnings below regarding the physical motion of plugging the device in).
Areas of possible concern
- If the external display carries power to the device (meaning you do not have to plug it into an AC outlet)
- In the case of a PC tower and a PCI type video card. If the screws are not installed or not tight you run the risk of inadvertently unplugging the card from the databus which could cause the system to behave unexpectedly. (in Windows can cause the blue screen of death)
- aland's comment on 3 phase power brings up a good point. There can be situations when the display and pc are connected to different outlets that could cause serious issues. In short if the notion of "ground" is not the same for the display and pc it could damage both of the display and laptop. While this damage would occur even if you powered down your display, it's still worth noting. I have seen this very issue with a cheap China direct Dell power supply blow up USB devices because it's notion of ground was 60V below the device's ground reference.
Closing Thoughts (Almost)
If the external display is a 'normal' display and all of the hardware is installed per the manufactures recommendations you should have zero troubles. You could always look up the video card / laptop's manual as well as the monitor's manual to be safe.
EDIT
Additional Thoughts
After reading sawdust's answer and doing a bit more digging I happen to come across a duplicate question here on SU. The more I read on it it really boils down to a few points.
- Because the nature of electricity, it will be hard to find a display that states that it is 100% safe to hot plug the device.
- While there may not be a data sheet that shows it, but when so many people (dare I say hundreds of thousands?) have done this for years with no trouble it is hard to dispute a give track record this positive and large.
When trying to answer the question "Should I....", it becomes a calculated risk (as any real world problem is). Take a moment to answer these questions and it should give you your answer. There can be many more variables to the calculation, but this should at least get the point across.
Business Environment Variables
1) How long does it take to power down and up an average business grade laptop?
2) How much does it cost the company per minute of your time?
3) How many times per day would you connect and reconnect the display?
4) What is the cost of a new PC + display?
5) What is the percentage of 'safe' operation?
Do you see where this is going? By powering down and back up each time you want to move your machine several times / day it could quickly become evident that buying a new machine + display would be cheaper in the long run. Please note that if you switch a lot during a meeting with a number of employees, the cost per minute skyrockets.
Personal Variables
This is much more simple...
1) Do you want to minimize all of the possible risks?
2) How patient are you?
3) How much faith do you have in the proven track record of hot plugging the display?
Closing Thoughts
While I can say that there is a not 100% certainty that nothing bad will happen to your display / machine, IMHO the time savings and large proven track record makes the risk a very acceptable one.
-
2One thing though: if you have three-phase power, pay attention to plug both PC and display to the outlets powered by the same phase. My friend killed both video card and a projector when he was installing new PC in one of university's classroms. However, this refers to all electrical equipment, but I think it may be appropriate here.– alandSep 9, 2011 at 20:20
-
@aland: This is worth noting, but does would cause an issue even if AndriodNoob powered down his machines before connecting. Sep 9, 2011 at 20:30
-
Regarding the Business Environment Variables, the highest costs is actually that letting your clients wait 5 minute while you reboot your laptop looks highly unprofessional. Many laptop's VGA plug doesn't come with screw hole to let you know that you don't need to screw them, they were designed for 5 minutes presentations and all OSes since XP (or even before) were designed so you can hotplug a display and the external monitor will be automatically recognized and configured. I'd say hotplugging VGA monitor is perfectly safe, it's part of the design.– Lie RyanSep 10, 2011 at 0:14
-
@Lie Ryan: I completely agree with it looking bad infront of the customer. I also fully agree with the OS being able to detect them on the fly etc... but some display manuals (see the link in my edit above) say that to reduce the risk both the display and pc should be shut down. Please note that I do not do this, I have hot swapped them for many years and still plan to do so. Sep 10, 2011 at 0:49
-
@Adam Lewis: mobile phones carries absurd warnings about radioactive signals and putting it close to your head and causing your head to explode and mutated babies. Manufacturers put weird things in manuals to comply with regulations and ward off lawsuits that never happens. While some warnings have its merits, I doubt this one do.– Lie RyanSep 10, 2011 at 1:11
Consult the owner's/operator's manual of the display device. Most likely the manual states that both display and PC should be powered off when connecting them. Obviously this would be the safest and no-risk method.
The capability of connecting devices while one is powered on (aka hot-plugging) is partly determined by the connector design. If the electrical ground connection(s) cannot be established before any power and then signal lines are connected then there would be the chance of damage to line receivers. Inspect a USB device connector and you'll see that the contacts are not all of the same length; note that USB devices are hot-pluggable.
Neither VGA (HD-15) or DVI connectors are designed for making ground before signal, so there could be some risk when connecting powered devices. Just because someone has done it without problems does not mean that you never will. BTW I've seen electricians work on live circuits, i.e. they don't shut power off to replace a outlet; just because it can be done does not mean it should be recommended to others.
I kept plugging my HP dv5 to an external monitor while both on for a while till one day all of the sudden as soon as I plugged in VGA to the laptop, the laptop went blank. The monitor was fine but the laptop's either main or video processor went out.
The risk of hot swapping is too high. From now on I prefer to lose 2 - 3 minutes rather than the laptop.
I've learned the hard way (twice; I'm a slow learner) to always turn off the display device before plugging a VGA cable into a computer. There seems to be a possibility of sending a power surge from a live monitor back to the computer, damaging the computer's video board.
Years ago, we had a DataTrain monitor that was misbehaving.
In a fit of frustration i unplugged, plugged in, unplugged, plugged in, unplugged, plugged in, ... the monitor cable from the video card.
The monitor never worked again.
So i don't do that anymore.
answered Sep 9, 2011 at 19:26
-
5This sounds like you broke it...not really a rational explanation to this one. Sep 9, 2011 at 20:04
-
It wasn't mechanical damage; it was electrical. In other words unplugging and plugging in a monitor with the monitor turned on is bad for it.– Ian BoydSep 10, 2011 at 0:19
-
2@Ian Boyd: before suspecting that the monitor was damaged because of the unplugging and plugging action, I would suspect that it was much more likely that it's already damaged before you first unplug it, you did say that it was misbehaving.– Lie RyanSep 10, 2011 at 1:07
-
From my experience of TV repairs, we see a lot of problems due to hot swapping HDMI cables. In theory this can be done.
In practise it is very risky. Remember that pin 18 of HDMI is a 5v source supply which is to be used to switch the HDMI port inserted. This supply may cause issues when conflicting with the internal 5v used by the TV.
I always tell our customers to avoid this risk. Putting in standby should be enough.
I strongly suggest NOT hot-plugging! Been there, done that...twice. Years ago we used to connect a laptop(it was sometimes the guests' machine) to the TV on a daily/weekly basis. It was all good until one night, all of a sudden, plugging the HDMI made both the powered on devices go black...The TV needed a semi-expensive repair, while the laptop got away with just its HDMI port 'burnt' and unusable. We didn't understand what went wrong and therefore, it happened again the following year...This time, though, the laptop also needed a repair! So yeah - never ever for the sake of saving 2 mins! :)
