It's bothered me for a few months now, but I can't take it any more ;p Whenever I try to open a .url shortcut (Steam games or OneDrive shortcuts to OneNote notebooks for example) a print dialog shows up. I have no idea why this is happening. I've created an imgur album with detailed pictures explaining the problem.
I'm using Windows 10 1709. I've been searching for a solution, but I haven't found one that helped me, so I decided to ask the people here.
Edit: File association dump