-1

I am using an LCD with my laptop. When the LCD gets off, all windows on the LCD are shifted to the laptop screen automatically. So I have to rearrange them myself.

By using the VGA cable I'm not facing this issue. But must I use an HDMI cable, as I don't have VGA port in my machine.

4
  • This behavior is "by-design" and it should stay that way. If the windows don't get moved to the remaining display after you have powered-off or disconnected one, then you will have no way of accessing them and this will become a major usability problem Aug 10, 2018 at 10:41
  • Then Why not it happens in case of VGA cable?
    – Sibtain
    Aug 10, 2018 at 11:50
  • it does occasionally happen in case of VGA cable
    – phuclv
    Feb 27, 2019 at 17:27
  • @phuclv Now I am using VGA and its working fine. I was facing issue while using HDMI cable. Don't whats the matter but I am happy now. Thanks
    – Sibtain
    Mar 27, 2019 at 9:48

1 Answer 1

0

It's simply because Windows sees that the monitor has now been disconnected and you have one less monitor available. Therefore it'll try to move windows on that screen to the visible ones

It's not related to the connection type but whether the monitor chooses to leave the connection active while it was being turned off or not. I've seen the behavior on both display port and HDMI.

For example many TVs leave their HDMI ports on while they're in standby mode or showing another source, therefore the OS thinks that the monitor is still on even though the screen is invisible. As a result it leaves the multi-monitor configuration as-is. The same thing happened with some of my display port monitors. But some others turn the signal off right after I press the power button, which results in what you observe

That phenomenon applies to even VGA cables. You may see that in your case but that doesn't mean it always works like that. The VGA port doesn't maintain an active connection without DDC, so the PC can't reliably detect whether a monitor was attached or not. That's the reason why sometimes the proper resolution can't be obtained due to a bad cable or an ancient monitor and the output will be distorted/squeezed/whatever

See also

2
  • I asked for the solution,not for the explanation that how it works.
    – Sibtain
    Aug 20, 2018 at 6:34
  • @MuhammadSibtain the only question in your "question" is Then Why not it happens in case of VGA cable?. There's no solution to your problem because it's not a real problem after all. If you want buy a new monitor that keeps its connection alive when it's turned off
    – phuclv
    Aug 20, 2018 at 6:35

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .