1

I've a strange problem with my trusty T410 (2537-26G) which has been working great with the factory-standard 4Gb RAM stick in the machine's only slot. I've tried replacing the stick with various 8Gb sticks, but am getting consistent freezes no matter which brand etc. I am trying. I have gone through three different sticks now (all brand new, and from different brands and vendors over more than a year) and they all show the same behaviour:

  • When I boot the machine and let it run, it freezes within a few minutes.
  • When I boot the machine into a memory testing program, it will freeze within seconds.

Prior to freezing, I am able to verify that it does indeed report 8Gb of memory. I am 100% sure that the memory I have bought is correct in relation to clock speed, etc.

Putting in my old 4Gb stick immediately fixes all problems except my need for more memory. So I am wondering: could there be a hardware fault in the laptop itself? Might this be a known issue? I have been unable to dig up similar complaints on the 'net so that's why I now ask here. (Not that I think it's an OS issue, but I want to state that the behaviour is the same across three different Linux OS'es.)

single slot machine

2

The new RAM must be unsuitable for the ThinkPad T410.

RAM selection is very touchy, as the RAM must obey very strict limitations imposed by the motherboard, and in addition some specs are never published.

The Lenovo page of Detailed specifications - ThinkPad T410 says :

image

The specification of "1 GB, 2GB, or 4GB memory" is the most important, as it seems to mean that the motherboard does not support one RAM stick of more than 4 GB.

An important support for this understanding of the phrase comes from the Crucial analyzer, which does not offer any 8GB stick for your computer. The only 8GB combination it offers is the Crucial 8GB Kit (2 x 4GB) DDR3L-1600 SODIMM, which has two sticks of 4 GB.

  • I've spent so much time reading the specs oh-so-carefully (or so I thought), and had the understanding that 8Gb is the maximum. But then, how can they write that, when the single slot can only take up to 4Gb? – KlaymenDK Oct 16 '18 at 19:51
  • The specs say that you have two slots. Two 4GB sticks make together 8 GB. – harrymc Oct 16 '18 at 19:56
  • Then I've no idea where that other slot is, and I thought I knew ThinkPads pretty well. I've added a photo to the post. And no, there's no secondary slot or on-board RAM underneath there. – KlaymenDK Oct 16 '18 at 19:57
  • Yeah I'm trying to find a computer that will play that YouTube link. I'm getting errors everywhere. – KlaymenDK Oct 17 '18 at 14:19

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.