0

From microsoft documentation of chkdsk command, it has the following commonly used switches:

/f
Fixes errors on the disk. The disk must be locked. If chkdsk cannot lock the drive, a message appears that asks you if you want to check the drive the next time you restart the computer.

/r
Locates bad sectors and recovers readable information. The disk must be locked. /r includes the functionality of /f, with the additional analysis of physical disk errors.

/b
NTFS only: Clears the list of bad clusters on the volume and rescans all allocated and free clusters for errors. /b includes the functionality of /r. Use this parameter after imaging a volume to a new hard disk drive.


Q1:
Does it mean /r switch will scan for both logical errors in files (logical file corruptions) and physical HDD damages (like bad sectors)?


Q2:
If /r switch does scan for bad sectors, will it scan the entire HDD (both used and free areas) ?


Q3:
Do the differences between /r and /b lie in that /r will skip scanning for the sectors previously marked as bad sectors while /b will scan all sectors (no matter normal or bad)?

Therefore, /b will update the list of marked bad sectors, which means releasing false-positive bad sectors for normal usage (This often happens when cloning an old HDD with bad sectors to a brand new HDD which should have no bad sectors in ideal case). Am I correct?


Q4:
If my understanding is correct in Q3, then I would wonder about the mechanism of determination for bad sectors.

Suppose there is a bad sector(already marked as bad) in old HDD and it is not 100% dead practically, so it could read once in several attempts. Then I clone the old HDD to a brand new one, so the bad sector records are also copied to the new HDD.

If now I run chkdsk /b for the brand new HDD, will there be a chance that this abnormal sector will be released as a normal sector for read/write? That sounds dangerous and unreliable.

Is it worth to use /b for the brand new HDD after cloned?

4
  • Yes for all 4 questions. That sounds dangerous and unreliable. Why? bad sector in old HDD and it is not 100% dead, so it could read once in several attempts After first failed (write/verify or chkdsk /r) attempt it must be marked as bad and it will never be used in future until format, chkdsk /b or similar action. – Akina Feb 21 '19 at 11:15
  • @Moab Will /b also scan the entire disk surface? – Grace Feb 22 '19 at 7:56
  • According to your research, yes. – Moab Feb 22 '19 at 13:25
  • @Akina Thanks for your quick response and clear explanation, would you like to paste your explanation as answer, so I can mark it as answer. Thanks. – Grace Feb 23 '19 at 4:09
0

Firstly credit to Akinaand Moab

Answers for all 4 questions are yes.

Furthermore, /b switch will scan the entire disk surface.
And after first failed attempt (write/verify or chkdsk /r), the bad sector must be marked as bad and it will never be used in future until format, chkdsk /b or similar action.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.