I have this system based on the Intel D510MO motherboard, which is basically an Atom D510 (dual-core HT Atom w/built-in GPU), an Intel NM10 chipset, and a Realtek Gigabit LAN controller. It's entirely passively cooled. I noticed almost immediately that there was a kind of very, very soft noise that corresponded with graphics operations, sort of the noise you'd get if you had a sheet of flat paper and slid something really light across it — but more electronic than that. I wrote it off as observation error and/or disk activity triggered by the graphics operation (although the latter seemed like a lot of unnecessary disk activity).

It isn't.

I got curious enough that I finally did a few controlled experiments, and here's what I've determined:

  1. It isn't the HDD. For one thing, the sounds the HDD makes (when seeking, when reading or writing, when just sitting there spinning) is different. For another, I used sudo hdparm -y /dev/sda (I'm using Ubuntu 10.04 LTS) to temporarily put the disk on standby while making sure that non-disk graphics op was happening in a loop. The disk spun down, but the other sound continued, corresponding perfectly with the timing of the graphics op. (Then the disk spun up again, but it takes long enough that I could rule out the HDD.)
  2. It isn't the monitor; I ensured the two were well physically-separated and the sound was definitely coming from the main box.
  3. It isn't something else in the room; the sound is coming from the box.
  4. It isn't cross-talk to an audio circuit coming out the speakers. (It doesn't have any speakers.)
  5. It isn't my mouse (e.g., when I'm trying to make graphics ops happen); the sound happens if I set up a recurring operation and don't use the mouse at all, or if I lift the mouse off the table slightly (but enough that the laser still registers movement).
  6. It's not the power supply (or at least, not the big AC->DC part of the power supply, which is an external brick; obviously there is further power conditioning that occurs internally from the 9V DC feed).
  7. It isn't the voices in my head; they never whisper like that.

Other observations:

  • It doesn't seem to matter what the graphics operation is; anything that changes what's on the screen seems to do it. I get the sound when moving the mouse over the Chromium tab bar (which makes the tab backgrounds change); I get it when a web page has a counter on it that changes the text on the page: I get it when dragging window contents around.
  • The sound is very, very slightly louder if the graphics op is larger, like scrolling a text area when writing a question on superuser.com, than for smaller operations like the tick counter on the web page. But it's very slight.
  • It's fairly loud (and of good duration) when the op involves color changes to substantial surface areas. For instance, when asking a question here on superuser and you move the cursor between the question box and the tag box, and the help to the right fades out, changes, and fades back in. (Yet another example related to the web browser, so let me say: I hear it when operations completely unrelated to the web browser as well.)
  • It doesn't sound like arcing or anything like that (I'd've shut off the machine Right Quick Like if it did).
  • Moving windows does it. Scrolling windows (by and large) doesn't.

I have the feeling I've heard this sort of thing before, when all system fans were on low and such, with other systems — but (again) written it off as observational error. For all the world it's like I'm hearing the CPU working (as opposed to the GPU; note the window scroll thing above) or data being transferred somewhere, but that just seems...unlikely.

So what am I hearing?

This may seem like a very localized question, but perhaps other silent PC enthusiasts may be interested as well...

  • 1
    Very interesting. I think I have heard what you are talking about too but brushed it off as disk IO. You should get your hands on a Mechanic's Stethoscope to poke around on the inside (on heatsincs) to see where the noise is the loudest. – James T Jun 6 '10 at 22:31
  • @James: Hadn't heard of a mechanic's stethoscope, but the phrase is pretty clear about what it is. :-) Yeah, the next step pretty much has to be opening it up and seeing which part the sound actually comes from. – T.J. Crowder Jun 6 '10 at 22:39
  • 1
    lol... if you do a google search on mechanics stethoscope... you'll see what i mean. – James T Jun 6 '10 at 22:44
  • 1
    I've got an HTPC that I replaced several parts on, until I figured out it was the half-height nvidia card - made an annoying noise that only bothered me. Sometimes you just have to figure these things out! – Jared Harley Jun 7 '10 at 4:20
  • @James: Oh, I just need one of those. On order. :-) – T.J. Crowder Jun 7 '10 at 5:44

It may be a capacitor or a voltage regulator, they can emit some pitched electrical/magnetic noise when put under load. This thread discuss a similar problem.

alt text

  • 1
    Any type of coil device can do this. Transformers are especially noted for that, as they physically vibrate during operation at any appreciable load (for their size). – Brian Knoblauch Jul 19 '10 at 12:46
  • 3
    That's neither a capacitor nor a voltage regulator. – Paused until further notice. Sep 4 '10 at 19:50
  • 1
    +1; @Dennis, a coil is a main component of a switching voltage regulator, and it can emit sounds. There are a plently of these regulators on a motherboard, as switching ones are more effective than linear ones. – whitequark Dec 3 '10 at 13:13

I'd take a guess on something in the power supply. Can you record it, and analyze the frequency? Perhaps some sort of harmonic? Basically, anything on the AC side of the power supply can resonate - could be a bad component, something a bit loose, or just low-quality parts.

  • Drat, I left the power supply off the list. (It's not the power supply -- well, not the main AC->DC part of it, anyway -- that's an external brick.) Still, good point, as one thing that would change is the power draw of the GPU (erm, I think). – T.J. Crowder Jun 6 '10 at 22:37
  • 1
    GPU is probably the biggest power draw. If it's not the power supply it still could be power related. Once you open it up, and are tracking down the noise, get a wooden pencil with an eraser on the end of it. Use the eraser to lightly touch components to see if you can alter the sound. – chris Jun 6 '10 at 22:46
  • 2
    Capacitors and inductors anywhere on the system, not just in the power supply, can hum. Those ferrite cores on the motherboard or graphics card with copper wrapped around them are inductors used to smooth out current flow. They are also - by definition - electromagnets and depending on how well wrapped and epoxied they are can make tiny mechanical oscillations whence sound. – msw Jun 7 '10 at 0:35
  • @msw: Yeah. I have a mechanic's stethoscope on order to find out. :-) – T.J. Crowder Jun 7 '10 at 5:45

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.