0

Is it reliable? I can't seem to find name brand RJ-45 to USB adapters anywhere ...makes me a bit skeptical of the whole thing. Is it just a wire conversion or are there inline resistors/caps/ICs?

6
  • The useful limit of a USB cable length is much less than an Ethernet cable. I would not consider doing this.
    – John
    Aug 29 '20 at 18:32
  • What do you mean by using it for wifi backhaul, in this case? What devices do you have in mind? Are you planning to run an Ethernet cable and connect it to a USB port, or are you planning to run a USB cable that connects to Ethernet ports?
    – user1686
    Aug 29 '20 at 18:36
  • Well, I'm going to be using a RPI3B+ as a temporary wifi router and bridge so I need it to have two wired ethernet connections. One is built-in, the other I would have to kludge with a Ethernet-over-USB adapter. Backhaul means taking the packets sent via wifi and sending them up stream on the wire to another router, basically is my understanding. Convert a USB port to an Ethernet port is my plan. Aug 29 '20 at 18:42
  • John, that's good to know, well the device would be within five feet so I think voltage drop wouldn't be an issue. Aug 29 '20 at 18:45
  • If you can find a connecting device, 5 feet will not present any limitation for either length or speed.
    – John
    Aug 29 '20 at 19:31
2

There are literally a zillion of these things -- just look on Amazon for "usb ethernet adapter" and you'll have your choice of them.

They are actually very reliable. If you look at most new thin laptops, you'll find that many do not have ethernet ports anymore. They use USB Ethernet adapters instead.

Now, some caveats...

  1. The 3B+ only has USB2. USB 2 is kinda slow. So, while you can find gigabit usb ethernet adapters, you wont get that speed.
  2. USB on the Rpi3B+ handles everything... ethernet, usb ports, wifi, SDCard, etc. So, while it will still work, be aware that the USB bus could get saturated. The ethernet port on the rpi3b+ is actually a usb ethernet adapter built into the rpi.
  3. The rpi CPU may not be beefy enough to handle all of this traffic, especially if you think you'll be trying to shove 100mbit across each interface.
  4. Double-check me on this one, but I think the entire USB bus on the 3b+ is limited to 41MBps or 328mbps. That really isn't much for 3 network adapters to share, along with everything else crammed onto that bus.

From a reliability standpoint, there's no reason to think it wont be reliable just because it's a usb ethernet adapter. If there's a reliability problem, it will most likely be in the 3b+'s USB bus capacity.

What you are trying to do, conceptually, is a great idea for an rpi. But, in all honesty, I'd suggest you use an rpi 4 instead. It's USB bus is 10x faster (USB3 vs USB2) and it's onboard gig ethernet has been separated from the USB bus. Plus, it has a faster CPU and more memory.

1

Is it just a wire conversion or are there inline resistors/caps/ICs?

It's not anything like a wire conversion – a computer's USB controller is physically incapable of understanding the Ethernet signal.

Instead, these are fully active devices containing a bridge IC which speaks USB on one side and Ethernet on the other. They receive Ethernet data frames and forward the data through a USB endpoint, and the OS has a driver which presents it as a network interface. Fundamentally this works the same way as a PCI-based Ethernet card would.

(In fact, the built-in Ethernet port on older Raspberry Pi versions was internally attached through USB in basically the same way as these external adapters.)

I can't seem to find name brand RJ-45 to USB adapters anywhere ...makes me a bit skeptical of the whole thing.

The adapters are assembled by various brands, but internally they commonly use chips produced by reputable companies such as ASIX (e.g. AX88179) if you're lucky or Realtek (e.g. RTL8153) otherwise. However, their Linux driver support varies.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.