Super User is a question and answer site for computer enthusiasts and power users. It only takes a minute to sign up.
Sign up to join this community
I recently formatted and reinstalled Windows on my laptop. It now runs much faster. I have been doing this about once a year for the past decade. Why is this needed?
I always figured this had to do with installing and removing programs, which over time fill up the registry with junk. Is this true? Are there any programs that can tweak the system without reformatting?
The registry is a bit of a misconception, The way it works, it could be filled with junk but it shouldn't slow down your machine - imagine, all roads are linked, but just because there is a traffic jam somewhere doesn't always mean it will affect you somewhere completely different!
It is pretty much just software that starts with your computer, updaters and bad drivers.
You can greatly speed up your computer using Microsoft / Sysinternals AutoRuns and delete/disable enries you do not want to start up with your machine.
P.S. I'm a software developer.
The biggest slow downs are:
The crap-ware you keep installing. If you don't use it, un-install it. Before installing anything ever again, do a little research into what the best apps are to do what your trying to do without a lot of overhead (post such a question on SuperUser--you'll get rep points!)
The next biggest thing is your anti-virus and other "security" type software. Throw that all away and learn how to surf safely. If you must download something from an unknown source, run it through virustotal.com before executing. I don't care what they say you can survive just fine without anti-virus software running on your machine. I'm not saying you should shut off windows firewall, just don't add an anti-virus or internet security suites.
No, even if the registry was massively bloated there would be little impact on the performance of anything other than exhaustive searches (ed. of the registry itself).
is a quote (in the comments) by Mark Russinovich, who is a widely recognized expert in Windows operating system internals as well as operating system architecture and design.
Up to this point nobody has proven him wrong with extensive unbiased tests, that involve multiple reboots, multiple computers, different sets of software and can easily be reproduced. It's one of those myths that get debunked amongst many other so-called performance improvement tips, simple because nobody has even reproducible claimed that the cleaning on its own improves performance. Because really, removing entries that aren't even touched while your PC boots is not going to have much effect.
What mainly slows down your PC are AREs (automatically running entries) which you can clean with AutoRuns, this tool list the following: Logon Applications, (Internet) Exprorer extensions, Scheduled Tasks, Services, Drivers, Codecs, Boot Execution Code, Image Hijacks, AppInit and KnownDLLs, WinLogon, Winsock Providers, Print Monitors, LSA Providers, Network Providers and Sidebar Gadgets.
Over time, these applications themselves load more information which is what makes software like Disk Cleanup come to existence. CCleaner these days does quite well on enumerating most of the files of most of the software you have, however you will want to stay away from its registry cleaning capabilites with have a higher chance of breaking something than giving you any performance benefits.
The most well known locations where this happens are the Temporary folders of Windows as well as caches and history files and folders of your browser, these are files and folders that are actively used and thus play a big role in your performance. Other files may include those referenced to by the registry or by configuration files on your computer. Keeping the amount of software and files / folders on your system to those that you actually might help as well.
So, to summarize:
Cleaning the registry does not make the registry smaller, but leaves blank space behind.
Compacting the registry to remove blank spaces can be done with NTREGOPT as administrator.
The registry itself does not become slower as its size grows.
Entries in the registry can affect the performance of your installation, mostly the AREs entries.
Files on your system that are referenced by the registry or configuration also play a big role.
Make sure you regularly get rid of viruses, software you don't need and cleaning out old files.
Here's what Chris Pirillo from Lockergnome (famous for his TECH on CNN) has to say:
I tune up customer PCs regularly. While each PC is different, the changes that have the most impact generally are:
I've tried a variety of register cleaners/compactors/etc. over the years, and they've never made a difference I could detect.
The first data written on a hard disk can be retrieved faster:
For a clean install you will probably use only the fastest part of the hard-disk. With an old computer your harddisk is probably full and/or system files (updates, etc) are written to the slower part of the hard disk.
Since Windows 2000 realized I was trying to understand when and why Windows OSes start to work slowly. And I found the reason and the cure.
The reason is audio/video codecs. Do not install any audio/video codec! Even DivX is not necessary. Codec packs are evil. :) In Windows any installed codec is a windows driver. Any driver slows the boot time and the general performance.
The cure is VLC player. This one don't require any codecs, they are embedded.
Since then all my systems (Windows OSes) almost don't lag, boot fast, and never hangs.
One case of real-life measurements about how registry cleaning can improve performance is found in the article : Putting Registry-/system-cleanup apps to the test. Please note that to arrive at a situation where registry slow-down occurred, the tester installed CNET’s list of the 20 most popular Windows downloads. This is his summary of the measurements of boot and shut-down :
Here is the explanation of why does this arrive.
The registry is a simple-minded database, and has the distinction of being one of the slowest database systems in the world. In an attempt to somewhat protect it, Microsoft has partitioned it into 5 separate hives.
Over time the registry becomes larger and larger as new programs are installed, used and removed. Even though data is deleted from it when applications are uninstalled, the size of the Registry will not decrease. This is because the data will be marked as blank but remains in place and also because of "left overs" - data that the uninstaller forgot to remove. In this way the registry becomes slower over time, taking longer to access.
There are many products to clean up the registry, but that doesn't help much if one doesn't then also re-compact it, in this way erasing the blank spots occupied by deleted data. As the vast majority of registry-cleaners do not do compaction, they are in effect useless.
A computer whose owner likes to try out software products, installing and uninstalling, may benefit from registry cleaning and compaction, but only after quite many such operations. Please note that any improvement will only show up for registry access, which is normally only a small part of what any normal program does. Some products for whom registry access is a major activity are for example the Windows boot and Installer.
Computers whose setup is relatively static, have nothing to worry about, so have no need for registry cleaners.
Cleaning and compacting the registry is not a 100% process. So once a slow-down is experienced, registry tools may improve the situation, but can never compare for speed with a clean installation of Windows.
