I have an NTFS hard drive which I've been reading/writing to on my iMac using NTFS-3G / Tuxera. The reason that it's NTFS formatted is because it came out of my old PC. Its singular function is the storage of a ton of multimedia -- MP3s mostly, with the occasional video and image files thrown in. I only recently started buying new hard drives but still haven't copied the files over -- mostly because of this problem.

One day, I started noticing that some of my MP3s in iTunes would not play, as they could not be located. When I pulled up Finder to look at the drive, I noticed that the directory where they were all stored had been transformed into a "Unix executable" file. It has the exact same name and modification date as the directory -- a few years ago, which was the last time the main directory was modified, not counting a lot of recent changes to the files inside it -- although its filesize is less than 100K. My drive is still showing the same amount of used/available capacity.

I've scoured several spots online but wasn't able to come up with a similar scenario. Just to reiterate the details:

  • NTFS drive being read/written to using NTFS-3G/Tuxera for Mac OS X
  • iMac uses 10.6.8 at the time the error first occurred
  • Drive shows that its free/used space is the same
  • Phantom Unix file has same name and modification date as the directory

Before I break out Data Rescue, which is my next step, I was wondering if there were any other steps I could take, or if my drive is borked and I might as well just reformat it... Any suggestions?

  • I know this has happened to me before. It was a picture file that had no extension and happen to have the X permission on. Adding an extension and turning off the X bit fixed it. But I'm not confident this will help with an NTFS hardlink. – surfasb Nov 17 '11 at 18:36
  • For NTFS, chkdsk on Windows might help; it's a Windows native filesystem after all. (Then again, it might destroy the folder completely while "fixing" it.) – user1686 Nov 17 '11 at 20:50
  • May be it's time to use PhotoRec? – Vi. Dec 8 '11 at 21:18

Since NTFS is a proprietary file system developed by Microsoft you can never be certain about whether third party drivers are working properly. Sure, NTFS-3G might be working most of the time, but still they can't deliver such reliable drivers as Microsoft, if only they would put some out. I know this sounds woolly. But when I started on the Mac, I lost about half of my music library to the bad support of NTFS through third party drivers. So to know your data to be safe on a Mac it is warmly recommended to use HFS+ or at least exFAT, if you need to transfer Data between Windows and OS X.

What you can do now:
As long as most of the data is still accessible on the drive, try to get it off the NTFS partition and reformat it to HFS+. It would be for the best to use a Windows machine, hooked up to the iMac via ethernet, to transfer the data off the drive and store it on a HFS+ drive connected to the iMac


Connect the drive to a Windows machine, and then see if the folder works. (This might even work from a Windows VM running in Virtualbox.) If so, copy the folder to a new drive or partition, HFS+ preferably.

I guess the drive is an external HD, and then it shouldn't be too difficult to find someone who has a Windows machine. I think an Ubuntu machine would work as well. It's probably readonly, but that's not a problem if your only goal is to copy data from that disk to another one. (Virtualbox + Ubuntu is free to download, but I don't know if that will solve your problem.)

If you don't have access to a Windows or Ubuntu machine, do not touch the drive, or make an image of the drive, and use the image for testing until all data is safe.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.