I have been reading the FAQs at witopia.net, publicvpn.com, and other VPN providers, and I see why their services might be valuable when I use my computer or smartphone at a WiFi hotspot. But what about when I use my smartphone with AT&T's 3g cellular data? Will a VPN make my data more secure, or does 3g already include comparable encryption?


3G does include encryption, however, it has been broken and cannot be assumed to be secure.

If you are handling sensitive data on any wireless link, you should always encrypt. For many jobs the HTTPS encryption available in web browsers is sufficient. So if you wanted to read your personal emails via a web browser, that is all you need. Similarly, if using a mobile email client, ensuring that POP3S or IMAPS is enabled is sufficient.

If, on the other hand you need to log in to an enterprise system containing customer or payments data, you really should be using a VPN so that the end-to-end conversation is encrypted.

  • While I agree with most of the contents of this answer, I think that if you own or trust the (wireless) connection then VPN connection won't help much (e.g., no advantage to use VPN while on your home WiFi) – Timotei Jan 23 '16 at 20:48
  • You certainly have a point. It would be fairly extreme to run a VPN on your home network unless you really wanted to to be highly secured. – Julian Knight Jan 23 '16 at 23:20

At the end of the day, even if 3G and 4G are totally secure, you have the internet at the other end of it, which is definitely not secure. So yes, VPN will make your cellular connections more secure.

Then again, a VPN just gets you securely onto a remote network. From there, if you browse the internet, then again, it's just going back out over the internet. But if your aim is to more securely get to a remote network, then yes, VPN is the way to go.

The other thing VPNs can provide in some cases is anonymity (assuming you don't then go and do something personally identifiable like log into your facebook account or MSN or whatever via the link!), and in this case, VPNs definitely improve on the situation vs vanilla 3G/4G cellular internet. But don't confuse anonymity with security :)

  • 1
    A VPN does not give you any anonymity. Possibly quite the opposite since the VPN system itself will almost certainly be logging your use. There is, however, a class of VPN that is designed to given better anonymity, largely linked to the TOR system. As you point out, the purpose of a VPN is to get a secure local network connection from a remote location. – Julian Knight Jun 28 '12 at 8:49
  • Sorry, I should have been clearer about VPN anonymity: a VPN on its own doesn't guarantee anonymity; however, if you choose your provider correctly and are careful how you use it, it can provide some level of anonymity. TOR can provide full anonymity, however it can also get you into a lot of trouble, especially if you make yourself an edge router. It's also quite slow and not suitable for bandwidth intensive purposes, so it has its own set of problems. – Jon Kloske Jul 4 '12 at 0:06

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy