26

I don't understand how bash evaluates escaping of apostrophe characters in single quoted strings.

Here is an example:

$ echo ''\''Hello World'\'''
'Hello World' # works

$ echo '\'Hello World\''
 > # expects you to continue input

I've tried looking for explanations to this but couldn't get anything. What is bash doing here?

1
  • echo \''Hello World'\'
    – math
    Nov 13, 2012 at 8:11

4 Answers 4

23

In single quotes, no escaping is possible. There is no way how to include a single quote into single quotes. See Quoting in man bash.

5
  • 1
    You're right. The trick is in that line 'A single quote may not occur betweeen single quotes even when preceded by a backslash' So it probably splits it into different parts.
    – Kibet
    Oct 1, 2012 at 10:31
  • @Colin As soon as a single quote is inside of two other single quotes (but backslashed), the quoted quote isn't a real quote anymore. It is just a char with no special pairing characteristics.
    – zero2cx
    Oct 1, 2012 at 11:14
  • 1
    @zero2cx: Not true: echo '\''
    – choroba
    Mar 31, 2014 at 21:00
  • @zero2cx: I would say "outside" instead of "inside".
    – choroba
    Apr 1, 2014 at 16:14
  • 3
    @choroba not "totally" true, in bash you can do echo $'\'hello world\''
    – bufh
    Dec 17, 2014 at 14:58
12

In addition to POSIX-supported single- and double-quoting, bash supplies an additional type of quoting to allow a small class of escaped characters (including a single quote) in a quoted string:

$ echo $'\'Hello World\''
'Hello World'

See the QUOTING section in the bash man page, near the end of the section. (Search for "ANSI C".)

1
  • It's great! Thx
    – Mikl
    Jan 21, 2020 at 15:43
7

Simple example of escaping quotes in shell:

$ echo 'abc'\''abc'
abc'abc
$ echo "abc"\""abc"
abc"abc

It's done by closing already opened one ('), placing escaped one (\') to print, then opening another one (').

Alternatively:

$ echo 'abc'"'"'abc'
abc'abc
$ echo "abc"'"'"abc"
abc"abc

It's done by finishing already opened one ('), placing quote in another quote ("'"), then opening another one (').

What you did ('\'Hello World\''), is:

  1. Opened 1st apostrophe:'.
  2. Closed right after it \', so the string becomes: '\'.
  3. Hello World is not quotes.
  4. Placed standalone apostrophe (\') without opening it.
  5. Last apostrophe (') is opening string, but there is no closing one which is expected.

So the correct example would be:

$ echo \'Hello World\'
'Hello World'

Related: How to escape single-quotes within single-quoted strings?

0
4

To explain what is happening with your escaped apostrophes, we'll examine your second example (also see single quotes, or strong quotes):

$ echo '\'Hello World\''
>     # expects you to continue input

Here, you've left the quotation hanging, as you've stated. Now trim the end and change it to:

                     v                                v           v
$ echo '\'Hello World     # Echo two strings: '\' and 'Hello World'.
\Hello World         ^

The "Hello World" sub-string wasn't quoted here, but it behaved as if it was strong quoted. Using your example again, trim the end differently this time:

                     vv                                    v (plain apostrophe)
$ echo '\'Hello World\'   # Will echo: '\' and 'Hello World''
\Hello World'        ^^   # Note that the trailing ' char is backslash escaped. 

The "Hello World" sub-string again behaves as if it were strong quoted, with only the added apostrophe (escaped, so no longer a single quote) at the end.

When another single quote is added to the end (your original example) the string is left hanging and waiting for a close-quote.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.