I have a VirtualBox machine representing a "clean" install of my OS. I would like to use this VM for several types of machines - one for simple games, one for programming, one for my audio editing. So basically I want three or four (maybe more later) VMs which I can start up depending on what I'm doing. From what I understand, both clones and snapshots could serve my purposes. I could either make a separate clone for each VM I want, or just branch off several snapshots of the base machine and install all of my tools on each one.

The only basic difference I can think of is (1) I can't run multiple snapshots of the same machine at the same time (or can I?) and (2) clones would take up more space on my HDD (since the whole virtual HDD would be cloned multiple times).

Note that I'm not concerned with running multiple VMs at the same time, I only want to run one at a time.

Are there other differences I'm not thinking of?


Your difference (2) is erased if your clones are "linked clones" rather than "full clones". Linked clones use differencing disks just as snapshots do. Then the real differences from snapshotting are that snapshots can be made from a running VM; and furthermore your point (1), which occurs because each snapshot has the same disk ID (UUID). In contrast, each cloned disk is assigned a new disk ID (UUID). The distinct disk IDs permit cloned disks to run concurrently.

| improve this answer | |
  • So to clarify: If I create "linked clones", then (1) I could run multiple VM's from the same "base" disk (at the same time??), and (2) the base disk basically becomes "read-only"? That sounds like exactly what I want. – loneboat Feb 18 '13 at 17:03
  • Yes. Well, I have only carefully read the documentation. Although I was using snapshots this week, I have not actually tried using clones at all. – minopret Feb 18 '13 at 17:06

Both: Start with clones, then snapshot them before you make crucial changes, or whatever changes you might want to roll back. Example, your programming and decided you need to add some library that might kill your VM. I would make a clone of the base VM for each purpose you need one for.

| improve this answer | |

What I don't understand is why you want separate vm's if they are all base images you're creating... then you could have one vm to worry about, and snap shots would then work best for you

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.