5

With a blower type graphics card, I don't think it matters very much whether you arrange the fans in your case to provide positive, neutral or negative pressure inside your case, since the blower should be designed to move enough air through the heatsink and out of the case to adequately cool the graphics card.

It is possible that a positive pressure cooling arrangement might provide a slight advantage, since your graphics card fan is working with rather than against the pressure differential, but I that imagine the benefit is minimal.

With a graphics card which uses an open cooling system, where some of the air may be exhausted from the case, but where some (or all) air is circulated back into the case I wonder which cooling arrangement will give the most efficient cooling (to minimise power, noise and component temperatures).

From the research I have done so far, it seems that blower type graphics cards are recommended for a positive pressure cooling situation, while negative pressure cooling is recommended for open cooling graphics cards, but I'm not so sure.

For example, lets consider a case with inlet fans at the front and outlet fans at the back (ignoring the added complication of side or top fan mounts):

    ------------           ------------   
    <  <   <   |           <  <   <   |   
Out <  <CPU<   |       Out <  <CPU<   |   
    <  <   <   |           <  <   <   |   
    |          <           |          <   
    <<<GFX<<<  < In        <<<GFX>>>  < In
    |  ^^^     <           |  ^^^     <   
    |          |           |          |   
    ------------           ------------   
  Blower design GFX       Open design GFX

With an open design graphics card and positive pressure cooling, the <<< flow may be increased due to the advantageous pressure differential, but the >>> flow may be decreased due to the incoming air from the In fan.

With negative pressure cooling, the <<< flow may be decreased due to the disadvantageous pressure differential, but the >>> flow may still be decreased due to the incoming air from the In fan.

From an intuitive perspective, I wonder if a neutral pressure arrangement (where intake and outflow fans are balanced) might not be a better option with an open design graphics card.

I also wonder if there would be a significant advantage from adding internal baffles, such that airflow from the front fan is directed up to the CPU and down to the graphics card intake, but away from the recirculating air of the graphics card:

    ------------   
    <  <   <   |   
Out <  <CPU<   |   
    <  <   <_  |   
    |        \ <   
    <<<GFX>>> >< In
    |  ^^^  _/ <   
    |          |
    ------------   

I know that a few years ago, case manufacturers went through a phase of promoting cases with airflow zones, but such cases never seemed to have a significant advantage (in noise/thermals) over un-zoned cases, so I suspect the effect might not be significant.

It is also possible that a positive positive pressure cooling, with vented blanks close to the graphics card could encourage the recirculated air to leave the case sooner rather than later.

Unfortunately, I don't know enough about the physics of cooling or fluid dynamics (laminar vs. turbulent flow etc.) to be able to assess the likely effect of these options. In my research, the closest I could find was a brief mention of the effect of open graphics cards on cooling in a Toms Hardware Guide article and that doesn't offer any concrete advice on this configuration.

So, overall, which airflow design option, if any, is likely to provide the best balance of thermals, noise and power when using a single open cooled graphics card?

References:

3

Negative pressure:

In comparisons the negative pressure is more effective, it just gets dirty easier. Thats nothing a little canned Air can't fix a few times a year though.

Benefits For Negative:

  • Good cooling performance for performance-oriented situations
  • Amplification of natural convection
  • Linear and direct air flow
  • Compatible with all direct heat exhaust graphics cards (the ones that blow dissipated heat out of a vent built into the shroud)
  • Augments the cooling performance of downward-facing CPU heat sink fans

With positive pressure air in the case could potentially not leave the case, bringing the ambient temp inside the case up above the room's ambient temp.


Update

Per your setup you pointed out:

The GPU itself is relatively neutral. So what you should worry about is how to keep the coolest air in the case. The case air will then pull from the case, and out the back through the GPU shroud and exhaust on the card. Negative pressure would provide on average the coolest air making this still the better option

  • @MarkBooth Do you have vented blanks for the GPU to vent out? Or will you pull a blank? – Austin T French May 22 '13 at 13:53
  • @MarkBooth I update my thoughts – Austin T French May 22 '13 at 14:51
0

I'd suggest: Positive pressure inside the case is good to discourage ingress of particles. Turbulence is good to increase heat transfer. Baffles, or any other obstacles, are likely to be bad by reducing efficiency (hence increasing power requirement, noise and heat load).

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.