I have Western Digital Caviar Black drive (model WD2002FAEX-007BA0).
System is running Linux Mint 14. Filesystem on drive ext4.

Recently I've got some i/o errors on one of the files. Then I've checked smart and saw Current_Pending_Sector count go up. (few sectors, don't remember exact number)

I've copied all information to another disk and tried to do several badblocks check (in read-only and non destructive mode) using following commands

fsck -vck /dev/sdb1 and fsck -vcck /dev/sdb1

After each scan it reported more and more badblocks. Current_Pending_Sector went as high as 90. Since drive is 2TB, each full scan takes up to day to complete. So I decided to selectively scan only block ranges with badblocks on that partition.

badblocks -b 4096 -sv -p 2 /dev/sdb1 48696066 48674506

after few scans badblock reported more that 1K errors. Then I've decided to wipe whole partition and do destructive write test with badblocks on whole drive.

badblocks -wsv ~/bb-sdb.txt /dev/sdb

but badblocks didn't reported any errors, and magically Current_Pending_Sector went to zero.

Full SMART status available here(pastebin)

Question is why Current_Pending_Sector went to zero? (I understand meaning of pending sector, but question is rather why it went down after full destructive write scan) And can I still trust this drive?


The issue you had most likely result of Silent Data Degradation Through using "badblocks" regulary I am trying to resolve it. From my expirience some disks more affected to Silent Data Degradation and some less. Here is some reading regarding Read Instability


To answer original question: No, I should have not trust that drive anymore. Couple months after described problem drive died. It became undetectable by system. Luckily, I had full drive backup, so no data was lost. Second drive (exact same model and capacity) still works with no problems

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.