11

I am currently paying for internet through SuddenLink which has offered me 50Mb download and 3MB upload. I have also bought a VPN through PrivateInternetAccess, which has pretty much doubled my download speed while downloading files encrpyted from my ISP.

The speedtest.net has shown with the VPN running with 128Mb down and 10Mb up.

Please Note The Data Encryption is BlowFish, Data Authentication is SHA256, and the Handshake is RSA-4096.

I have been told that this is not possible at all by several people, but when I go to show them the results from actually downloading a file and the speedtests, we are all confused.

Is this actually happening? As they are asking and were saying, is it the speeds which we see from the end-point of the VPN to the server which we are preforming the speed test to?

Also, I will provide screenshots of the speed test with and without the VPN also.

Update 1

I am not sure if this matters or not, but it may in the end. I live in a very, very rural location in West Virginia. I am lucky to not have 256K Dail-up internet thanks to my ISP, SuddenLink. I am starting to think it could be a congestion issue with my region?

  • 1
    How are you testing your transfer? Many VPNs include data compression. If they content you are transferring as part of your test is compressible, then that would explain your results. OTOH, your ISP may have a poorly implemented bandwidth-limiter that isn't counting the VPN traffic. – Zoredache May 5 '14 at 23:31
  • indeed. try downloading an iso file. they generally dont compress that well. – Sirex May 5 '14 at 23:35
  • I already have downloaded Windows ISOs just to see all of the possibilities. The speed is still doubled for some odd reason. – Traven May 5 '14 at 23:36
  • The answer by @MariusMatutiae has a chance of being right, even if the "bandwidth limitation" may be unintentional and a matter of congestion for example by Netflix. You should repeat your tests at strange hours, such as early morning, to be sure of what you are measuring, and see if the speedtest.net is constant-speed or faster at the beginning. The (un)encoding is done in the CPU (or even offloaded to the GPU), so it shouldn't affect too much the line speed. – harrymc May 11 '14 at 9:28
  • This is most likely caused by a combination of bandwidth management, which your circumventing by using a VPN, and that your VPN uses some sort of advanced compression such as LZO. – nullmem May 11 '14 at 15:19
11
+100

In the past I have had the same effect with my ISP (in a rural area too, though this is but a coincidence).

The root of the matter was that he implemented a bandwidth limitation on port 80 only. This was especially obvious with speedtest.net, where the initial speed would peak, then decrease to less than half of its peak value.

I discovered by pure chance that this did not occur on OpenVPN, where I managed to obtain the peak speed value during the whole speedtest.net test. This was made possible by the fact that the site I connected to (my work site) has a very nice, very fast, large-bandwidth connection.

Alerted by this, I tried a large file transfer via scp, and, lo and behold, I achieved the same large speeds as with the OpenVPN, rather than the lower http speeds.

You may try the same, and see whether a bandwidth limit is applied on ports 22 (scp) and 21 (ftp). It is most illuminating to use files already significantly compressed like pdfs, since this will rule out the incidence of compression per se.

Though admittedly sloppy, these bandwidth limitations are still effective, since most people use the Internet only for downloading Web pages.

EDIT:

Strictly speaking, there is a way to test this: if you control the VPN server, you may stop any other activity on the server on port 80, and start listening for VPN connections on port 80; you will also have to modify the port you connect to on the client's program. Now, if your ISP is limiting bandwidth use on port 80, the VPN should clock at exactly the same speed as the non-VPN connection.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.