1

Windows' disk management tool says that Disk 1's partitions are healthy:

enter image description here

However, HD Tune Pro 3.50 sees one error on the disk:

enter image description here

enter image description here

What does "Healthy status" mean in Windows' disk management tool?

I use Windows 7 SP1 x64 Ultimate and all data is backed up.

  • A single error isn't an indication of an unhealthy disk. Of course "healthy" only is the status of the file system – Ramhound Sep 28 '14 at 0:35
  • @Ramhound How many errors should there be to declare a disk unhealthy? – Franck Dernoncourt Sep 28 '14 at 0:37
  • That is up to the firmware. – Ramhound Sep 28 '14 at 12:20
2

Couple of things going on.

First:

I haven't really played with Windows dynamic disks a lot, but you won't see status messages other than "Online" and "Healthy" very much unless you are doing things like fault-tolerant volumes. Reference.

All of your disks are basic. So disk errors will not cause the disk to go to "Unreadable" status, unless Windows could not talk to the drive at all but hasn't been told it's been removed, in which case it will go to "Failed" status. But if this disk is your system partition or has your page file, your system will likely freeze or bluescreen first.

I believe the usual situation where you'd see a disk go to "Unreadable" instead of "Healthy" is if it was configured as dynamic and part of a fault-tolerant set. If one of the disks in the set encountered errors on I/O, Windows would mark the disk "Unreadable."

Generally to monitor for disk read/write errors if you aren't doing fault-tolerant stuff, pay attention to the Event Viewer - failed I/O generates events.

Second:

Modern hard drives for a while do sector sparing and transparent remapping. If the drive develops a bad sector, it will internally remap that sector with a spare, and increase the Reallocated Sector Count you are seeing from the SMART data.

A couple of these are no big deal but if many of these develop then you should stop trusting the drive.

Anyway this is done without the OS's knowledge, unless the OS checks SMART data, so these errors don't even make it to Windows.

If the drive has remapped all of its sectors and is getting to the point where it tells the OS about sectors, you REALLY should stop trusting the drive and get your data off of it now. Take a look at your Event Viewer, under Windows Logs, then System, and check for a bunch of "disk" events. If you see these, take action to protect your data now.

I haven't used HD Tune Pro so I don't know if it's looking at some internally available map of sectors or is physically looking at each sector from the OS point of view. It's bad in any case.

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.