I am aware of hard drive encryption options like TrueCrypt and other tailor-made solutions, but I am curious as to whether Windows security provides any kind of protection for a drive that is removed or stolen from a PC. If I grant read-access to a directory only to members of one group, can any user access that directory after the drive is moved to another PC? What about accessing the drive from a Mac or Linux box?


Permissions alone can't protect a stolen drive. Linux and Mac won't honor NTFS permissions and you will be able to do what you want (provided you have the ntfs-3g driver). However, if you use NTFS encryption or the new Bitlocker (Vista Ultimate+), you'll be better off.

  • 4
    Windows doesn't honour NTFS permissions either; you can put the drive into another computer, and providing you're running on the other computer as administrator, it'll let you straight in. BitLocker is basically Microsoft's TrueCrypt-alike; there's another solution by PGP that provides similar function, although that's all I know about that. – me_and Dec 14 '09 at 16:57
  • Yes, but only if you're administrator. – John T Dec 14 '09 at 16:58
  • 3
    @JohnT - being an admin on a Windows machine is trivial - install Windows and use the admin account. If you're stealing a harddrive, you really think getting an admin account somewhere is hard? – warren Dec 14 '09 at 17:15
  • I didn't say anything about it being difficult. I was just implying that Windows does honour NTFS permissions with the exception of an administrator when using the drive on another computer. – John T Dec 14 '09 at 18:00

Windows Encrypted File System (look at the efs tag here) will lock away your data quite good.
But, like John points out, permissions are not the answer.

Permissions and related access control will only prevent users defined by the windows 'administrator' from accessing across their ownerships (that too within the limits of system stability and vulnerability).

Both TrueCrypt and EFS will protect your data within the limits of the encryption technology similarly. It would need someone to know your password (by whatever means) to reach your data.

But, having said that, I would prefer using TrueCrypt over EFS.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.