-1

Is there some reason why somebody doesn't create pure, clean copy of Total Commander for OS X?

Are there some technical, legal problems why all TC clones are so.... weird and not as usable as original TC?

closed as primarily opinion-based by LPChip, DavidPostill, ChrisInEdmonton, random Aug 31 '15 at 12:23

Many good questions generate some degree of opinion based on expert experience, but answers to this question will tend to be almost entirely based on opinions, rather than facts, references, or specific expertise. If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.

  • 3
    This is not really a question is it? Total Commander is a Windows application written for Windows users. Mac application adhere to a different UX and UI conventions. Hence there is no 'clone' of TC. If you are seeking a good replacement then use Forklift. It event has a setting to copy the TC shortcuts (F5 copy, F6 move, F8 delete etc.) – Jozef Legény Aug 31 '15 at 8:05
6

Here's why:

First, in 2004, Total Commander author C. Ghisler said in Total Commander forums that for Mac, there is MuCommander:

Für Mac gibt es den MuCommander:

http://www.mucommander.com/


Author of Total Commander http://www.ghisler.com

In 2014, this was discussed again by forum members in context of crowdfunding of OS X version:

What exactly do you want?

1) Ghisler creating TC for OS X? Won't happen if I understood his comments correctly. Has nothing to do with funding.

2) Someone else creating TC for OS X? Requires an agreement between the OS X author and Ghisler about the rights to the name of the program.

3) Someone else creating a software on the same (or higher) level as TC.

2) and 3) could be funded by the crowd or otherwise.

Author's post in the thread was, I quote:

A few years ago I started porting TC to Linux. It cost me about 6 month of my life, but the result was not really good:

  • unexplainable crashes with background functions (e.g. copy in background)
  • no plugins (obviously)

Therefore I think that even if I created a special version for OS X, it wouldn't be useful because there are no plugins. Even a few years after the release of the 64-bit version, there are far less plugins than for 32-bit, although most plugins could simply be recompiled.


Author of Total Commander http://www.ghisler.com

So you can see it is highly unlikely that author will create Total Commander port for OS X. So you won't see identical product. Perhaps someone would start making it via crowdfunding and with consent of the TC author (in questionable areas) but currently it seems that MuCommander is the recommended option.

And if someone really wants Total Commander on Mac, then he's already running it there. :)


EDIT: Anyone seeking software recommendations (instead of learning about reasons behind TCMD), visit Software Recommendations site.

  • Note: I have tried using TC on Linux (via Wine), and it works quite well, including plugins. I would expect similar behavior on OS X. – Piskvor Aug 31 '15 at 9:19

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.